Rose Eveleth, a reporter and host of NPR and CBC’s podcast Tested, dives into the heated intersection of sports and culture. She examines how two women boxers became focal points in the trans debate leading up to the Paris 2024 Olympics. The conversation touches on the dark history of gender testing, the emotional toll on athletes, and the role of AI in recruitment. Listeners will find a gripping analysis of fairness, identity, and the political battles shaping women's sports today.
Recent controversies in women's boxing highlight significant media misrepresentation and its harmful impact on female athletes' achievements.
The International Boxing Association's opaque policies raise critical questions about fairness and governance in the evolving landscape of women's sports.
Deep dives
Women's Boxing and Media Representation
The controversy surrounding women's boxing at the Olympics highlights significant issues in media representation and public perception. During a recent semi-final match, Algerian boxer Iman Khalif faced scrutiny not just for her performance, but for her gender identity. Major media outlets inaccurately labeled her as transgender, reflecting a lack of understanding and research into women's sports. Such misrepresentation can perpetuate harmful narratives and undermine the accomplishments of female athletes, particularly when these women are already facing scrutiny based on their appearance and performance.
The Role of the International Boxing Association
The International Boxing Association (IBA) has been at the center of the controversy due to its decision to ban certain female athletes based on unspecified tests. This decision came after the IOC stripped the IBA of its credentials, causing concerns over the eligibility and treatment of female boxers. The lack of transparency surrounding the tests and the rationale for the bans raises significant questions about fairness and equality in sports. As the IOC steps in to manage boxing for the Olympic Games, the situation exposes the deeper issues of governance and accountability within sports organizations.
Cultural Wars in Women's Sports
The current environment surrounding women in sports is heavily influenced by cultural and political tensions, particularly related to gender identity. This backlash often manifests in arguments centered around the supposed threat to women's sports by transgender athletes, despite the fact that the athletes in question, like Khalif, are not trans. These narratives are weaponized by individuals and groups aiming to promote an anti-trans agenda, overshadowing the athletes' hard work and dedication. This larger cultural war affects not just individual athletes but the entire landscape of women's sports, complicating the public's perception and the athletes' experiences.
How Imane Khelif and Lin Yu-Ting—two women boxers fighting in the gender category they were assigned at birth—became the targets of trans panic and subject to another round of “but is she woman enough?” at the Olympics.
Guest: Rose Eveleth, reporter and host of the podcast Tested, from NPR and CBC.
Want more What Next? Subscribe to Slate Plus to access ad-free listening to the whole What Next family and across all your favorite Slate podcasts. Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts by clicking “Try Free” at the top of our show page. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.