The Battle for the Future: The Mission of China's Underground Historians
Sep 27, 2023
auto_awesome
China's underground historians face immense pressure from Xi Jinping's war on historical nihilism. They make sacrifices to preserve histories the Party wants to erase. The podcast explores erasure of history, preservation efforts, and the persistence of Mao's ideas. It also discusses challenges faced by Chinese historians in preserving and sharing historical records.
China's underground historians make significant sacrifices to preserve histories that go against official Party history.
The Chinese government exerts strong control over the historical record, shaping the narrative and pressuring historians to conform to its version of history.
Deep dives
The Fight to Control China's Historical Narrative
The writing of China's history has always been a contested matter, with sacrifices made by historians throughout history. Under communist rule, the job of the historian has become increasingly dangerous, leading to the erasure of certain parts of history. In the podcast episode, Ian Johnson's book 'Sparks' is discussed, which highlights the battle for the future among China's underground historians. One example cited is the rewriting of local history in Duerong, where the destruction of temples during the Cultural Revolution was completely elided. The episode explores the dangers of controlling and erasing historical truths, emphasizing the importance of alternative histories that keep memories alive.
The Role of Official Historians and Government Control
The podcast delves into the work of official historians and the control exerted by the Chinese government over the historical record. The government sets guidelines and passes down documents that shape the narrative and ensure the ruling party's continuity. The passing of resolutions and holding of history work meetings are important in shaping the direction of historical accounts. While some historians and journalists try to push back and include marginalized narratives, the overall pressure to conform to the government's version of history is strong. The episode emphasizes the challenges faced by those within the system who try to resist and the limited impact they can have.
The Significance of Counter-Historians
The episode highlights the importance of counter-historians and their role in preserving alternative narratives and memories. These underground historians, such as Jiang Shui and Ai Xiaoming, play a crucial role in documenting and shedding light on events that official history tries to erase or downplay. Their work involves collecting and collating facts, testimonies, and eyewitness accounts, often in the face of personal risks. Their efforts contribute to a collective memory that challenges official narratives and offers a more nuanced understanding of China's history. The episode recognizes the impact and resilience of these counter-historians despite the difficulties they face.
The Challenges and Future of Chinese History
The podcast raises questions about the future of Chinese history and memory. The erasure of historical events and the lack of official acknowledgement pose challenges to preserving and understanding China's past. However, the episode also highlights the persistence and resilience of individuals and their efforts to keep memories alive, even in the face of government control and limited access to documentation. While the mainstream Chinese society may be separated from certain aspects of history, the episode suggests that alternative narratives and memories will continue to exist and have an impact. The future of Chinese history and memory will likely be shaped by digital technologies, international networks, and the pursuit of justice and truth.
Writing history in China has never been easy; China’s first historian, Sima Qian, was forced to choose between execution and castration and imprisonment. He chose the latter in order to finish his life’s work, Records of the Grand Historian. Now China’s keepers of inconvenient truths are put under immense pressure by Xi Jinping’s war on historical nihilism—viewpoints and memories that run counter to official Party history. Fighting a seemingly unwinnable battle against the state, China’s underground historians often make huge sacrifices to keep alive histories that the Party would like to erase. In the first of a two-part series on history and memory, Louisa and Graeme are joined by Ian Johnson, whose book Sparks: China’s Underground Historians and their Battle for the Future is out today.