Interview: George Selgin (The Secret Method Banks Use To Create Money)
Sep 16, 2024
auto_awesome
In this engaging conversation, George Selgin, a prominent expert on banking and monetary policy, unpacks the secretive methods banks use to create money. He challenges conventional views on bank operations, exploring how banks fund loans and manage risks. Selgin also discusses the evolution of electronic money and the complexities of the Federal Reserve’s interest rate policies. The talk touches on the implications of innovations like FedNow versus private payment systems, culminating in a humorous reflection on future economic debates.
George Selgin argues that banks primarily function as intermediaries, requiring real resources for settlement even while creating money.
The podcast critiques the notion that banks operate solely on credit creation, emphasizing the essential role of empirical evidence in understanding banking practices.
Deep dives
Debate on Bank Intermediation
The podcast delves into the long-standing debate over whether banks are intermediaries that borrow to lend or if they create money without needing to borrow. One side, represented by George Selgin, argues that banks are intermediaries and must secure funds from depositors or other sources to finance their loans. Conversely, critics claim that banks create money independently, negating the need for borrowing. Selgin emphasizes the significance of the settlement process in this argument, asserting that despite banks’ ability to create deposits, they ultimately require real resources for settlement.
The Importance of Settlement Processes
Settlement processes are vital as they determine how banks transfer funds between one another, necessitating real reserves at the time of transactions. Selgin clarifies that once a loan is made and spent, it creates a liability that must be settled with another bank. Even if banks can create loans or deposits 'out of thin air', the actual transfer of funds requires the availability of real money to finalize the transaction. This means that banks must always ensure they have sufficient reserves to cover these transfers, challenging the notion that banks can operate solely on credit creation.
Critique of Non-Intermediation Theories
Selgin critiques a specific working paper from the Bank of England often cited by proponents of the idea that banks don't act as intermediaries. He argues that this paper overlooks essential components of the settlement process, which he regards as indicative of the banking system’s dependence on real funds. By focusing on this one influential paper, Selgin aims to defend the intermediation viewpoint against the prevailing criticisms. His critique also suggests that without acknowledging the critical role of settlements, misunderstandings about banks’ functions may persist.
Empirical Evidence and Theoretical Considerations
The discussion highlights the need for empirical evidence to substantiate claims regarding how banks settle transactions. Selgin proposes that the actual function of banks in settling their interbank liabilities should be explored further to understand their intermediation roles better. He mentions that historical practices and modern technologies can influence how banks manage reserves and settle payments, potentially encouraging a more nuanced understanding of banking operations. By addressing these complexities, the podcast encourages listeners to consider the foundational aspects of banking practices beyond theoretical perspectives.
The Rebel Capitalist helps YOU learn more about Macro, Investing, Entrepreneurship AND Personal Freedom.✅ Come to Rebel Capitalist Live here https://rebelcapitalistlive.com/
✅Check out my private, online investment community (Rebel Capitalist
Pro) with Chris MacIntosh, Lyn Alden and many more for $1!! click
here https://georgegammon.com/pro
✅Rebel capitalist merchandise https://www.rebelcapitaliststore.com
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode