A carefree date turns sinister when a couple goes missing in Houston, leading to a chilling investigation filled with suspense. The discovery of their car sparks panic, unveiling a haunting crime scene that leaves loved ones shattered. Chilling parallels emerge with another infamous case, raising unsettling questions about a former boyfriend. As the investigation grapples with cold case complexities, the emotional toll on families becomes palpable. The ongoing search for justice highlights the difficulties of overcoming skepticism and technological limitations.
The brutal unsolved murders of Cheryl Henry and Andy Atkinson spotlight the ongoing pain and absence of closure for their families.
Despite advancements in DNA technology, the lack of conclusive evidence and leads has left the case stagnant for decades.
Deep dives
The Mysterious Disappearance
On August 23, 1990, 19-year-old Shane Henry became alarmed when her older sister, Cheryl, failed to show up for her ride to work. After sensing something was wrong, Shane left work to search for Cheryl, only to find that Cheryl's boyfriend, Andy Atkinson, was also missing. The family quickly reported Cheryl's disappearance to the police, who were then alerted by a security guard who found Cheryl's purse in an abandoned car. The ominous scene revealed cigarette butts, potential blood stains, and a sense of impending dread as family and friends awaited answers.
The Gruesome Discovery
Cheryl's body was discovered about 200 yards from the abandoned vehicle, naked and bound, with visible signs of violent assault. Her clothing had been mutilated, intensifying the horrific possibility of a sexual assault, which investigators considered a key element in the investigation. Meanwhile, Andy's body was found tied to a tree not far from Cheryl, displaying a similar brutal method of murder that indicated premeditated violence. The chilling nature of the crime scene left investigators and the families grappling with unspeakable loss and confusion.
DNA Evidence and Suspects
Despite the emergence of DNA technology, investigators faced an uphill battle as no matches were found for the biological evidence collected from the victims. Various potential suspects were investigated, but many were ruled out through DNA testing or alibis. Among them were Cheryl's ex-boyfriend, who refused to provide a DNA sample, and a friend whose sudden departure raised suspicions, though later ruled out as a suspect. The lack of conclusive evidence and returns in CODIS left the case stagnant, rendering it increasingly cold as time passed.
The Enduring Legacy of a Cold Case
After decades without resolution, a strange anonymous letter was received by the police, claiming knowledge of the murders and requesting payment for information, but it led to no further developments. Despite the advancements in forensic science and continuous efforts by the lead detective, the case remains unsolved, poignantly highlighting the pain suffered by the victims' families. The emotional impact of the unsolved murders persists, as parents and siblings grapple with loss while wishing for closure. As the case continues to haunt the community, the call for justice remains urgent, emphasizing that someone must have information that could lead to answers.
When what should have been a carefree date goes horribly wrong, the city of Houston realizes there’s a monster in their midst. Will they be caught in time?
If you have any information about the murders of Cheryl Henry & Andy Atkinson in Houston in 1990, please call the Houston Crime Stoppers tip line at 713-222-TIPS (8477).
If you are interested in listening to INFAMOUS: The Lake Waco Murders Part 1 & Part 2, please visit the Crime Junkie website, or listen wherever you get your podcasts!
We’re officially on the road! Crime Junkie Life Rule #10 Tour is in full swing and we can’t wait to see you soon!
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.