
New Books in Military History Phillips Payson O'Brien, "War and Power: Who Wins Wars--And Why" (PublicAffairs, 2025)
21 snips
Nov 11, 2025 Phillips Payson O'Brien, a military historian and Professor of Strategic Studies at the University of St. Andrews, presents a challenging view of warfare. He argues that modern military success hinges more on economic, political, and logistical factors than on mere troop numbers or decisive battles. O'Brien introduces his concept of 'full-spectrum power,' which includes leadership and alliance dynamics, while warning against oversimplifying military effectiveness. He emphasizes logistics over combat and examines lessons from history to navigate today's geopolitical landscape.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Great Power Is A Misleading Label
- The label "great power" is largely meaningless and hides real differences between states.
- Phillips Payson O'Brien urges replacing it with a more granular view of what creates power.
Full‑Spectrum Power Framework
- Full-spectrum power assesses economic, technological, political, social, and alliance strengths together.
- O'Brien says this reveals where a state truly has advantages or vulnerabilities in war.
Economy And Tech Are Foundations
- Economic and technological capacity is necessary to be an international power.
- O'Brien argues you cannot be a China or the U.S. today without those foundations.


