Fred Kaplan, a New York Times bestselling author and Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist, discusses the enigmas of nuclear strategy. He explores why nuclear weapons haven't been used since 1945 and reveals insights from declassified archives on U.S. presidential decisions regarding nuclear crisis management. Kaplan sheds light on the delicate art of deterrence during the Cold War and the moral quandaries faced by leaders. Notably, he examines Kennedy's shift from military force to nuclear diplomacy during the Cuban Missile Crisis.
U.S. presidents have repeatedly considered using nuclear weapons during crises, yet most conclude it could lead to disastrous consequences.
The evolution of nuclear strategy has shifted from massive retaliation to nuanced approaches that emphasize credibility and deterrence over outright conflict.
Deep dives
Nuclear Deterrence and Presidential Decision-Making
Numerous crises have prompted U.S. presidents to consider the use of nuclear weapons far more frequently than is commonly understood. Research indicates that while presidents and their advisors explore nuclear strategy rigorously, they often conclude that employing such weapons could lead to catastrophic outcomes. This tendency to avoid nuclear war stems from a recognition that there are no good resolutions available through its use. Historical contexts suggest that intelligent decision-making by leaders has played a vital role in averting the deployment of nuclear weapons.
The Complexity of Nuclear Strategy: From Massive Retaliation to Limited Options
The evolution of nuclear strategy has seen a transition from the concept of massive retaliation to tactical approaches that emphasize limited nuclear options. Early thinkers, like Bernard Brody, argued that the focus of military strategy should shift from winning a war to preventing one, advocating for a credible retaliatory capability. This led to nuanced strategies aiming to deter aggression without resorting to all-out warfare, with complexities arising from pressures to employ force in response to conventional attacks. The Cold War dynamics inherently required solutions that balanced aggression with the fear of mutual destruction.
Kennedy's Diplomatic Insights During Crisis
John F. Kennedy's handling of the Cuban Missile Crisis reveals significant insight into the role of a leader in navigating extreme geopolitical tensions. Despite pressure from military advisors advocating immediate action, Kennedy opted for diplomacy, understanding the grave consequences that could arise from rash decisions. Notably, his analysis of the Soviet situation and willingness to engage in negotiations ultimately averted potential disaster. This incident highlights how individual leadership can profoundly influence the course of history, particularly in the context of nuclear conflict.
The Legacy of Nuclear Warfare and Leadership
The discourse around nuclear warfare often reflects the ideological boundaries that leaders must navigate, often resulting in complex and paradoxical situations. General Curtis LeMay exemplified a viewpoint that viewed nuclear weapons as viable military tools, firmly believing that they could resolve conflicts. In contrast, more strategic, measured approaches advocate for the non-use of nuclear weapons, illustrating a profound dilemma that persists in military thought. Ultimately, discussions of nuclear conflict must revolve around maintaining credibility in deterrence while recognizing the impossibility of managing a limited nuclear exchange effectively.
Why is it that nobody has used the absolute weapon, the nuclear bomb, since 1945? Was it ever likely that the American arsenal would be used against the Soviet Union? Or was it created solely to prevent nuclear war? If the latter is true, how does a country create the false impression that it is willing to release a weapon of mass destruction? New York Times bestselling author and Pulitzer prize winning journalist, Fred Kaplan, has authored The Bomb: Presidents, Generals and the Secret History of Nuclear War. In this episode, he and James discuss the strategies and motives of those in control of the bombs in the face of multiple crises ... not all of which are generally known.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode