The hosts dive into holiday classics that have lost their sparkle, critiquing overplayed tunes like overcooked steaks. They humorously explore the quirky charm of songs like 'I Want a Hippopotamus for Christmas' and question modern arrangements. A critical look at a 1984 charity classic reveals its problematic themes, while reflections on 'Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer' highlight its cultural significance. Join the festive banter as they navigate the charm and flaws of holiday music!
The hosts argue that many holiday classics have lost their appeal and suggest it's time to retire certain songs, like 'Santa Baby.'
They advocate for updating holiday playlists with fresher, more engaging music to replace tired classics that no longer resonate.
Deep dives
Holiday Songs Overdone
Certain holiday classics that have lost their charm are highlighted, emphasizing that some songs have had their moment and should be retired. The conversation reflects a nostalgic yet critical take on popular tunes, noting that while classics like 'This Christmas' by Donny Hathaway remain timeless, others, such as 'Santa Baby,' often seem overly sexualized. The hosts suggest that many songs simply don't resonate anymore, hinting at the need for fresh selections during the festive season. For instance, 'Santa Baby' is critiqued for its lack of substantive artistry, feeling more like a gimmick than a musical staple.
Controversial Picks
Pets and holiday songs converge as the hosts tackle the challenge of identifying classics that no longer deliver. They mention 'What Child Is This,' a track often loved by many but described as somewhat dull and lacking excitement in its arrangement. This critical viewpoint encapsulates their belief that even otherwise respected carols can fall victim to becoming stale if not properly executed. Additionally, 'Rockin' Around the Christmas Tree' is brushed off as overly cutesy, showing their desire for more meaningful holiday music.
Nostalgia vs. Fresh Perspectives
The discussion navigates the fine line between nostalgia and the need for a change in holiday music. Historical tracks like 'Do They Know It’s Christmas,' which features notable artists, are viewed through a modern lens, leading to the opinion that it feels dated and lacks musical quality. The hosts also share a light-hearted moment reminiscing about older songs, pointing out the novelty of 'Grandma Got Run Over by a Reindeer' but questioning whether it still holds up today. Ultimately, they emphasize the importance of updating the holiday playlist to reflect more engaging and relevant musical choices.
Do you ever find yourself lacking on a little holiday cheer? Do the holiday classics seem a little drab and dull lately? Well you may not be alone - Check out Peter and Adam's list of holiday classics that just aren't giving the same cheer they used to. Which holiday songs are you tired of hearing?