Crime Junkie MISSING: Cherrie Mahan
22 snips
Sep 29, 2025 In 1985, Cherrie Mahan vanished steps from her home, sparking a decades-long investigation filled with chilling twists. A mysterious blue-green van, rumors of a Quaker cult, and anonymous letters keep the case alive. New leads link a man at the VFW to past allegations, while Buddy Montgomery's connections stir intrigue. Letters from him raise more questions than answers, and Janice's quest for closure leads to a call for public help. The tale underscores the importance of child safety and resources for abuse survivors.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Disappearance Near Home
- Cherry Mahan vanished in the 500 feet between her school bus stop and her home on February 22, 1985.
- Police and volunteers searched a five-mile radius with bloodhounds and helicopters but found no trace of her or belongings.
Early Investigation Focused On Family
- Investigators first considered Cherry a runaway and then intensely scrutinized her parents despite polygraph passes.
- Early investigative focus on immediate family shaped the initial course of the case.
Distinct Van Witness Reports
- Multiple witnesses reported a blue-green van trailing the school bus the day Cherry disappeared with a skier painted on its passenger side.
- The van image was reproduced on flyers and became a central lead in the search.