Caterina Fugazzola, "Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China" (Temple UP, 2023)
Sep 26, 2024
auto_awesome
Caterina Fugazzola, a Global Studies professor at the University of Chicago, delves into queer mobilization in China. She discusses the evolution of the tongzhi movement and their non-confrontational strategies under Xi Jinping’s regime. By emphasizing community narratives, activists manage to navigate social and political constraints effectively. The conversation also covers the complexities of LGBT activism's history in China, challenges in self-identification, and innovative educational initiatives in Hong Kong, highlighting resilience and adaptability within the movement.
Contemporary queer movements in China utilize community-oriented narratives and non-confrontational strategies to navigate an authoritarian political landscape effectively.
The evolution of LGBTQ+ organizations since 1997 highlights their adaptability in addressing critical issues while avoiding governmental scrutiny through strategic language choices.
Deep dives
Non-Confrontational Strategies in Chinese Queer Activism
Contemporary queer movements in China employ non-confrontational strategies to navigate political sensitivities while advocating for LGBTQ+ rights. Activists often prioritize community-oriented narratives over direct political engagement, which helps them avoid backlash associated with more conventional Western tactics like protests. By focusing on familial and relational discourses, queer organizations create safe spaces for dialogue, fostering acceptance without invoking governmental hostility. This strategic approach emphasizes adaptation and flexibility, enabling these groups to exist within a political landscape that is often hostile to overt activism.
Diverse Landscape of LGBTQ+ Organizations in China
The LGBTQ+ organizational landscape in China has evolved significantly, especially since the late 1990s, culminating in the establishment of various NGOs focused on different aspects of queer issues. Notably, the shift from viewing homosexuality as a criminal behavior in 1997 to its removal from the list of mental disorders in 2001 facilitated the growth of community networks. Organizations now tackle issues ranging from health rights to legal advocacy, employing different strategies based on their focus areas. For instance, groups like PFLAG China emphasize parental acceptance, while others tackle more difficult topics like conversion therapy through a legal lens.
The Role of Language in Queer Advocacy
Language plays a crucial role in shaping the strategies of LGBTQ+ organizations in China, as activists often carefully choose terminology to avoid the stigma associated with 'human rights.' For example, the term 'lawful rights' is preferred over 'human rights' to align their advocacy with the existing legal framework without invoking governmental scrutiny. This nuanced approach allows organizations to effectively address issues while maintaining operational safety. Such linguistic strategies enable these groups to articulate their agendas through acceptable channels, ensuring that their work remains under the radar of political authorities.
Resilience and Future Prospects of LGBTQ+ Activism
Despite facing various challenges and a more repressive political climate, the resilience of LGBTQ+ activists in China is noteworthy, as they continue to adapt and innovate in their approaches to advocacy. Although many organizations have had to operate underground or relocate outside the country, there remains a vibrant community striving for change. The ongoing sharing of resources and communal support signifies a shift in how queer identities are understood and expressed in contemporary China. Looking forward, there is cautious optimism that as political conditions become more favorable, these marginalized voices will be heard and their rights increasingly recognized.
After China officially “decriminalized” same-sex behavior in 1997, both the visibility and public acceptance of tongzhi, an inclusive identity term that refers to nonheterosexual and gender nonconforming identities in the People’s Republic of China, has improved. However, for all the positive change, there are few opportunities for political and civil rights advocacy under Xi Jinping’s authoritarian rule.
Words Like Water: Queer Mobilization and Social Change in China(Temple UP, 2023) explores the nonconfrontational strategies the tongzhi movement uses in contemporary China. Caterina Fugazzola analyzes tongzhi organizers’ conceptualizations of, and approaches to, social change, explaining how they avoid the backlash that meets Western tactics, such as protests, confrontation, and language about individual freedoms. In contrast, the groups’ intentional use of community and family-oriented narratives, discourses, and understandings of sexual identity are more effective, especially in situations where direct political engagement is not possible.
Providing on-the-ground stories that examine the social, cultural, and political constraints and opportunities, Words like Water emphasizes the value of discursive flexibility that allows activists to adapt to changing social and political conditions.
Caterina Fugazzola is Assistant Senior Instructional Professor of Global Studies at the University of Chicago.
Qing Shen is a PhD candidate in anthropology at Uppsala University, Sweden.