Guest Brianna Sacks, a climate change and extreme weather reporter for the Washington Post, discusses the devastating fires in Maui, questioning accountability and Hawaii's response. They explore lawsuits against Hawaiian Electric, trade-offs of power shut offs, and the confluence of disasters and historical tensions. They analyze the recent fire, emphasizing the need for improved firefighting preparedness and training.
The convergence of dry conditions and strong winds, along with a problem with the grid, led to rapid spread of fires in Maui.
The response to the fires in Maui highlighted the need for accountability in disaster response, better infrastructure, and improved communication during emergencies.
Deep dives
The Devastating Fires in Maui
The recent fires in Maui have been shocking with a rapidly rising death toll and widespread destruction. These fires have become the deadliest in Maui's history, spreading so fast that people were forced to jump into the ocean to escape. The downtown area of Lahaina has been severely damaged, leaving many homeless. The scale of the loss is hard to imagine, but it is a familiar sight for reporter Brianna Sacks, who has covered similar devastation in California and Colorado. She highlights the need for accountability in disaster response and questions if anything went right in Hawaii's reaction to the fires.
Multiple Disasters Unfold
The fires in Maui were the result of a convergence of multiple disasters. The dry conditions on the island, combined with the hurricane offshore that brought strong winds, created a perfect environment for the fires to spread rapidly. The fires were often ignited by arc flashes, caused when power lines come into contact with vegetation, resulting in electrical explosions and subsequent fires. This pattern repeated throughout Maui, causing one fire after another. While it's not definitively proven that power lines caused the fires, there is evidence suggesting a problem with the grid.
Questions of Response and Preparedness
The response to the fires in Maui has raised questions about both the electric company and emergency management. There are allegations that the power company should have shut off power due to the high winds to prevent fires. The lack of warning systems and communication during the fires led to chaos and confusion among residents. Additionally, the capacity of the Maui fire department, which is not a wildfire-specific department, was spread thin as they tried to tackle multiple fires across the island. There is a need for better infrastructure, including underground power lines, to prevent such devastating fires in the future.
Hawaii is in flames, with the death toll from fires on Maui exceeding 100. Now, the search for where the failure—or multiple failures—occurred begins.
Guest: Brianna Sacks, reporter covering climate change and extreme weather for the Washington Post.
If you enjoy this show, please consider signing up for Slate Plus. Slate Plus members get benefits like zero ads on any Slate podcast, bonus episodes of shows like Slow Burn and Dear Prudence—and you’ll be supporting the work we do here on What Next. Sign up now at slate.com/whatnextplus to help support our work.