On The Persistence of Racist Pseudo-Science (w/ Keira Havens)
May 8, 2024
auto_awesome
Science writer Keira Havens discusses exposing racist pseudo-science and the fallacious reasoning used to rationalize social hierarchies. She highlights the misdeeds of figures like Charles Murray and Steven Pinker, exposing their bad arguments. Keira emphasizes the dangers of biological essentialism and how proponents of toxic ideologies gain mainstream acceptance. The discussion challenges genetic determinism in evolutionary psychology and advocates for critical thinking and awareness of environmental influences.
Identifying and exposing racist pseudo-science involves recognizing individuals who hide their harmful beliefs to gain credibility and promote toxic ideologies.
Mainstream researchers like Charles Murray and Steven Pinker perpetuate pseudo-scientific ideas that normalize hierarchies and dehumanize individuals based on biological essentialism.
Deep dives
Introduction to Box of Rocks Series and Relation to FTX Collapse
Kara Havens introduces her Box of Rocks series exploring biological essentialist arguments and racist pseudoscience. She links the series to the FTX collapse, highlighting the lack of good business practices and a race for the future. This aggressive pursuit without considering the suitability of individuals in charge is emphasized.
Linnaeus and Divine Will in Biology
Kara Havens discusses Linnaeus's belief in reading divine will in nature, determining closeness to God based on species characteristics. She highlights the belief in a natural order reflecting divine intent, challenging the notion of a fixed hierarchy in nature. The discussion extends to the misconception of interpreting natural order and the dangers of rigidly adhering to it.
Critique of Jordan Peterson’s Lobster Argument
The conversation shifts to Jordan Peterson's lobster hierarchy analogy, questioning the value neutrality of observing natural hierarchies. The emphasis is on the tendency to select negative examples like lobsters or chimpanzees to justify hierarchies and the problematic nature of romanticizing natural order. The discussion broadens to include critiques of Stephen Pinker's evolutionary explanations and societal implications.
Implications of Genetic Determinism and Social Hierarchies
Examining genetic determinism and social hierarchies, the podcast delves into how societal views impact the treatment of individuals. Examples like Stephen Pinker's writings are highlighted for mainstreaming pseudo-scientific ideas, with a focus on the dangers of dehumanization and its historical consequences. The conversation warns against the normalization of hierarchies that justify discriminatory actions based on biological essentialism.
Get new episodes early at patreon.com/CurrentAffairs !
Keira Havens is a science writer whose blog series "Box of Rocks" aims to identify and expose racist pseudo-science. She joins us today to explain some of the fallacious reasoning that is used to rationalize social hierarchies, and how proponents of toxic ideologies manage to cast themselves as mainstream researchers. We talk about the intellectual misdeeds of such figures as Charles Murray and Steven Pinker, and Keira shows us how to spot some of their bad arguments in the wild.
"As profoundly boring as biological essentialism is, some people are very into it. The ones that are honest about it are easy to spot. It can be harder to identify those that cultivate a careful aura of plausible deniability and then go about building the rest of their career. By hiding their philosophy, they gain access to institutions and platforms, allowing them to pave the way for other useful idiots and convince the next generation that Science Says™ some humans are better than others. The networks manufacturing credibility for their theory of eugenics are not shallow. They run deep, across decades, built by people that devote themselves consistently and continuously to the promotion of hereditarian philosophies." — Keira Havens, Box of Rocks
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode