
The New Thinkery Aristotle on Moral Responsibility (Nicomachean Ethics Book III.1–5)
Jun 14, 2023
The hosts dive deep into Aristotle's Nicomachean Ethics, discussing the nuances of moral responsibility. They explore how to distinguish voluntary from involuntary actions and what that means for praise and blame. A fascinating look at the 'mean' in moral virtue reveals the challenges in character formation. Philosophical questions about desire and choice provoke debates on personal responsibility. Finally, they question whether the pursuit of understanding the good should take precedence over assigning culpability.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Virtue Anchors the Human Good
- Aristotle links virtue to the human good because external goods are contingent and can be lost.
- Virtue remains when chance strips away possessions, making it central to flourishing.
Pig Temptation As Comic Example
- The hosts joke about Greg blaming pig temptation for his actions to illustrate claiming lack of control.
- The playful story shows how people dodge blame for shameful acts while claiming credit for noble ones.
Virtue As A Skillful Mean
- Moral virtue is a mean between excess and deficiency shaped by habit and practice.
- Hitting that mean requires skillful aiming and self-reflection, not mere formulaic rules.








