In this insightful discussion, John Rappaport, a law professor at the University of Chicago, dives into the intriguing topic of police labor mobility. He reveals how policies often trap officers in stagnant positions, complicating accountability and fostering a concerning trend of 'wandering officers'—those who move between departments despite past misconduct. Rappaport discusses the impact on community safety, the role of police unions, and presents the idea of a national database to enhance transparency. This conversation sheds light on the urgent need for reform in law enforcement practices.
The systemic barriers in police departments, such as restrictive pension systems, hinder officer mobility and contribute to misconduct issues.
Wandering officers, often hired due to staffing shortages, pose significant risks as they show higher rates of serious misconduct compared to their peers.
Deep dives
The Issue of Wandering Officers
Wandering officers, defined as those who have been fired from a police department only to secure employment elsewhere, present a significant concern within law enforcement. Research indicates that around 2% to 3% of police officers in Florida fall into this category, translating to approximately 1,100 individuals actively working despite past misconduct. These officers are not just seeking better opportunities; they frequently encounter serious misconduct complaints at nearly double the rate of their peers. The systemic issues leading to their continued hiring suggest a troubling cycle where communities may unknowingly employ officers with problematic histories.
Barriers to Police Officer Mobility
The research highlights that despite the notion of job mobility being prevalent in many professions, police officers often experience significant barriers when attempting to change positions. Many officers remain in their positions for extended periods, with about 70% having only one job throughout their careers. Factors contributing to this stagnation include the natural monopoly of police departments in small towns and restrictive pension systems that penalize officers for switching jobs before vesting in their benefits. These barriers create an environment where officers may feel trapped, potentially leading to dissatisfaction and eventual misconduct.
Incentives and Misconceptions of Police Behavior
The pressures surrounding local police departments often force them to hire wandering officers due to staffing shortages, especially in smaller agencies that struggle to attract candidates. These departments may mistakenly believe that hiring previously fired officers will yield better performance due to their experience. However, research reveals that these officers tend to engage in misconduct at heightened rates, raising concerns about the long-term implications for community interactions and trust. This paradox reflects deeper systemic issues within the hiring practices of law enforcement agencies, where the urgency to fill positions may overshadow the need for thorough vetting.
Implications for Policy and Reform
The findings advocate for a reevaluation of current hiring practices and propose the establishment of a centralized database to monitor police misconduct and employment histories effectively. Such a database could help inform hiring decisions while enhancing transparency within law enforcement agencies. Additionally, by addressing the systemic causes that perpetuate the hiring of wandering officers, such as poor labor mobility and pension limitations, reforms could be implemented to elevate the standards of policing across jurisdictions. Ultimately, fostering a more informed and agile workforce may lead to a reduction in misconduct and improved community relations.
Police rarely move between jobs and departments. But according to a paper co-authored by the University of Chicago law professor John Rappaport, officers aren’t necessarily choosing to stay in the same place—a lot of policies have made it costly for them to switch. And that lack of mobility can have all kinds of ripple effects.
Get more from your favorite Atlantic voices when you subscribe. You’ll enjoy unlimited access to Pulitzer-winning journalism, from clear-eyed analysis and insight on breaking news to fascinating explorations of our world. Subscribe today at TheAtlantic.com/podsub.