Professor Christopher Gill discusses Plato's Atlantis, its connection to his other works, recurring catastrophes, historiography, the structure of Atlantis, and contrasting virtues between Athens and Atlantis.
The Atlantis story serves as a manifestation of the ideal state and embodies the central theme of embodiment of the ideal in both physical and political aspects.
Plato's Atlantis story reflects his interest in historiography, transmission of the past, and the correlation between the material world and the ideal realm.
Deep dives
Plato's Atlantis Story and its Fertile Reception
Plato's Atlantis story, as presented in the Tameis and Critias dialogues, has gained significant attention and interpretation throughout history. Contrary to popular belief, Atlantis is entirely Plato's creation, with no previous mentions in antiquity. The story is divided into two parts, with the first half focusing on the creation story of the universe and the birth of humanity. The second part, presented in the Critias, tells the story of the war between Atlantis and primeval Athens. The Atlantis story serves as a manifestation of the ideal state and embodies the central theme of embodiment of the ideal in both physical and political aspects. The contrast between Athens and Atlantis is highlighted, with Athens representing unity, stability, moderation, and courage, while Atlantis exhibits structured complexity, growth, instability, and eventual corruption. The story abruptly ends, leaving the narrative of the war unseen, potentially because Plato wanted to focus on the philosophical exploration rather than delving into a lengthy epic. The Atlantis story reflects Plato's interest in historiography, transmission of the past, and the correlation between the material world and the ideal realm.
The Form and Structure of Atlantis
According to Plato's account, Atlantis is a vast and powerful island located in the western regions, being larger than Europe and Asia combined. The island is characterized by its intricate city planning and multiple rings of land connected by canals. At the heart of Atlantis lies a capital city with concentric rings and extensive underground irrigation systems, facilitating trade and exploiting the island's rich resources. However, despite its grandeur, Atlantis eventually suffers a sudden and catastrophic demise due to an earthquake and flood, leading to the disappearance of both the Atlantean army and the island itself. This fantastical end to Atlantis presents a striking contrast to the more stable and unified Athens of primeval times.
Contrasting Athenian Unity and Stability with Atlantean Change and Instability
The story of Atlantis brings to light the contrasting characteristics of ancient Athens and Atlantis. Athens represents unity and stability, with a single city-state centered around a political institution called the guardians. These guardians, numbering about 20,000, were virtuous warriors who practiced moderation and courage. Athens maintained its size, wealth, and population, whereas Atlantis underwent change and growth over time. Initially a small state, Atlantis expanded in both land occupation and political complexity. However, as wealth and complexity increased, corruption eventually infiltrated Atlantis, leading to its ultimate downfall. The presentation of these two states highlights the virtues of moderation and stability in Athens, while showcasing the dangers of uncontrolled growth and corruption in Atlantis.
The Enigmatic Ending and Philosophical Exploration
Plato's Atlantis story abruptly ends, leaving readers with a sense of incompleteness and uncertainty. It is speculated that Plato may have chosen to forgo the detailed narrative of the war between Atlantis and Athens as he wanted to focus on the philosophical exploration rather than delve into a lengthy epic. The story serves as a platform for Plato to delve into the embodiment of the ideal and the correlation between the material world and the realm of forms. While the Tameis and Critias dialogues differ in focus and presentation, they both demonstrate Plato's interest in history, the transmission of the past, and the connection between materialistic aspects and the ideal realm. The Atlantis story, as a whole, reveals the complexity of Plato's thought and his ability to surprise readers with unexpected narratives and philosophical reflections.
Christopher Gill, Emeritus Professor of Ancient Thought at the University of Exeter, takes us deep into the territory of Atlantis, one of Plato’s most puzzling creations.
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode