Dan Kois, a Slate writer and author of five books, discusses aviation safety in light of a recent tragic mid-air collision. He dives into the growing concerns of imminent airline crashes and the political dynamics that prioritize convenience over safety. Kois highlights the chronic understaffing in air traffic control and the historical context of the industry’s challenges. He also explores the public’s perception of air travel risks compared to more common dangers, raising questions about how society balances safety and risk acceptance.
The recent airplane collision highlights critical safety concerns stemming from chronic air traffic control understaffing and its consequences on operational effectiveness.
Political pressures and lobbying prioritize increased flight capacity over aviation safety, revealing systemic flaws that risk future air travel incidents.
Deep dives
Rising Concerns Over Air Traffic Safety
The recent collision between an American Airlines flight and a military helicopter has raised significant concerns about the state of air traffic safety in the United States. This incident marks the first major accident in fifteen years, prompting experts to reflect on longstanding fears of such crashes becoming more likely due to systemic issues in aviation. It has been reported that air traffic control staffing levels were below normal at the time of the crash, leading to one controller having to manage multiple responsibilities during a critical period. The chronic understaffing of air traffic controllers, coupled with the increasing number of flights, creates a dangerously high-pressure environment that poses risks to both pilots and passengers.
Impact of Political Decision-Making on Aviation
Political pressures have played a significant role in the challenges facing the aviation industry, especially concerning staffing and resource allocation. Congressional lobbying often prioritizes adding new flights over safety considerations, which has resulted in congested airports that may not safely accommodate the increased traffic. In the aftermath of the crash, politicians quickly shifted blame rather than addressing the systemic issues that have existed across multiple administrations, including a lack of funding for air traffic control positions. This cycle of reactive politics demonstrates a dangerous disconnect between operational safety needs and legislative action, leaving the aviation system vulnerable to future incidents.
Pilot Experience Shortages and Training Delays
The aviation industry is experiencing a crisis related to pilot shortages, exacerbated by the pandemic's impact on workforce levels. When airlines laid off many pilots during the COVID-19 pandemic, the rapid return of air travel created an urgent need for qualified personnel, which the industry struggled to meet. Training new pilots is an extensive process that requires thousands of hours of flight experience, resulting in a reliance on less experienced pilots who may be unprepared for high-pressure situations. This shortage directly affects safety in the skies, raising concerns about the overall expertise of the current pilot workforce and the long-term implications for air travel security.
America hadn’t had a major commercial airline crash since 2009 until the mid-air collision over the Potomac. Is this a sign of a larger problem that will require government intervention—and will Congress prioritize safety over convenience for their constituents and themselves?
Want more What Next? Join Slate Plus to unlock full, ad-free access to What Next and all your other favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the What Next show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/whatnextplus to get access wherever you listen.
Podcast production by Elena Schwartz, Paige Osburn, Anna Phillips, Madeline Ducharme and Rob Gunther.
