Exploring the shortcomings of modern democracy and its impact on institutions, including the erosion of essential institutions. Discussing the potential dangers of corrupt politicians in modern politics leading to totalitarian rule. Detailing the rise of soft totalitarianism in Western democracies and the call for alternative political systems.
Democracy can lead to a tyranny of the majority in direct democracy, while indirect democracy often fails to represent the people effectively.
Soft totalitarianism in democratic societies arises from state control, erosion of independent institutions, and the illusion of democratic rule.
Deep dives
The Fatal Flaws of Modern Democracy
Modern democracy, with its political campaigns, elections, and the illusion of rule by the people, has been criticized for creating a form of soft totalitarianism. While democracy is often upheld as the pinnacle of government, the reality is that it can provide cover for politicians and bureaucrats to enrich themselves at the expense of society. Instead of fostering social flourishing, democracy has led to the erosion of vital societal institutions like free markets, sound money, and strong families, questioning the true value of this form of governance.
The Fallacy of Direct and Indirect Democracy
The distinction between direct and indirect democracy highlights the challenges faced in modern democracies. Direct democracy, where citizens vote on specific issues, can lead to a tyranny of the majority, while indirect democracy, where politicians are elected to represent the people, often falls short in practice. In reality, a select few political candidates dominate the system, serving their own interests and those of special interest groups rather than the populace at large. The failure to produce ethical leaders and the unchecked growth of state power underscore the flaws inherent in current democratic systems.
The Emergence of Soft Totalitarianism in Western Democracies
Soft totalitarianism, as envisioned by Alexis de Tocqueville in the 19th century, has gradually taken root in Western democracies. Through a network of rules and controls, governments soften the will of individuals, directing and suppressing their actions. The replacement of independent institutions with state control, coupled with the illusion of democratic rule, has paved the way for the rise of totalitarian tendencies disguised within the framework of democracy. The gradual erosion of societal resistance and the subjugation of citizens to state power signal a dangerous trend towards soft totalitarianism in the West.
“Remember Democracy never lasts long. It soon wastes exhausts and [destroys] itself. . .It is in vain to Say that Democracy is … less proud, less selfish, less ambitious or less avaricious than Aristocracy or Monarchy. It is not true in Fact and no where appears in history. Those Passions are the same in all […]