Fred Kagan, a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute and a strategic military analysis expert, joins the discussion to delve into the complexities of modern warfare. He shares insights on Ukraine's military strategies and how the U.S. can navigate future conflicts with Russia. The conversation highlights the shifting dynamics of the Ukraine war, contrasting Russian and Ukrainian tactics, and touches on Putin's conflicted narrative on conscription. Kagan also addresses the implications of drone technology and the ongoing situation in Israel, connecting these geopolitical issues with historical contexts.
The restoration of maneuver warfare is vital for Ukraine to achieve significant territorial gains without high casualties in the ongoing conflict.
Technological advancements, specifically drones, have transformed warfare dynamics, creating challenges for traditional maneuver tactics and promoting positional warfare.
The war in Ukraine has significant implications for broader geopolitical dynamics, particularly influencing perceptions of American resolve among nations like China.
Deep dives
Restoring Maneuver in Warfare
A significant focus of the report involves addressing the need to restore maneuver in contemporary warfare, particularly in light of the Ukrainian conflict. The report emphasizes that maneuver warfare, characterized by large-scale movement combined with effective firepower, is essential for Ukraine to overcome its current positional warfare challenges. Ukrainian forces must find ways to conduct operations that allow for more significant territorial gains without incurring high casualties. The report draws attention to historical insights from Soviet military theory, which can provide valuable lessons for modern military strategy.
The Impact of Technology on Warfare
The advent of technology, particularly drones and electronic warfare systems, has significantly transformed the battlefield dynamics in Ukraine. The use of drones has created a partially transparent battlefield, making traditional maneuver tactics less effective and leading to a state of positional warfare. Both Ukrainian and Russian forces are utilizing drones for reconnaissance and precision strikes, which complicates large-scale offensive maneuvers. The need to adapt to this technological landscape, while leveraging innovations, is paramount for both sides to gain a strategic advantage.
Challenges of Positional Warfare
Positional warfare, distinct from an outright stalemate, presents unique challenges where both sides can engage in small territorial advances without decisive outcomes. The report highlights how Russian forces have effectively engaged in this type of warfare, resulting in high casualty rates for minimal gains. For Ukraine, successfully overcoming this battlefield condition requires strategic innovation and a shift away from costly, static engagements. A critical evaluation of battlefield conditions and a reassessment of tactics is necessary to enable Ukrainian forces to re-establish maneuver capabilities.
Ukrainian Incursions and Strategic Objectives
Recent Ukrainian incursions into areas like Kursk have raised debates about their strategic value and potential impact on Russian operations. Ukrainian leadership has articulated multiple objectives for these actions, including capturing Russian prisoners and disrupting enemy operations near the border. Despite preliminary success, the ultimate effect on major Russian offensives remains uncertain. The strategic calculus involves not just immediate battlefield outcomes, but also long-term implications for Russian military posture and capabilities.
The Geopolitical Implications of the Conflict
There is significant concern regarding how the ongoing war in Ukraine impacts broader geopolitical dynamics, particularly in relation to China and its ambitions in the Asia-Pacific. The potential for a perceived American fatigue in supporting Ukraine raises alarm about encouraging adversarial actions from nations like China. The likelihood of settling for a ceasefire or inadequate resolution could embolden such nations to reassess their military strategies against perceived vulnerabilities in Western resolve. Maintaining a robust stance in Ukraine is integral to deterring future aggression, as the lessons learned here may have far-reaching effects globally.
All right, enough. It’s time for a break from all the news. To lighten things up, Jonah brings on AEI senior fellow Fred Kagan to talk about war. Fred is the director of AEI’s Critical Threats Project and a leader in strategic military analysis, so this installment of The Remnant gives you a front row seat in the situation room. Fred and Jonah discuss the next steps for the Ukrainian army, how the U.S. can mitigate future conflict with Russia, and the minutia behind Russian military strategy that may place Putin at a disadvantage. They review the Kursk incursion, draw a distinction between the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and the war in Ukraine, and consider the future of the war in Israel.
The Remnant is a production of The Dispatch, a digital media company covering politics, policy, and culture from a non-partisan, conservative perspective. To access all of The Dispatch’s offerings—including Jonah’s G-File newsletter, weekly livestreams, and other members-only content—click here.