Church and the Crisis of Decline with Andrew Root | Episode 142
May 1, 2023
auto_awesome
Andrew Root, the Carrie Olson Baalson Professor of Youth and Family Ministry at Luther Seminary, dives deep into the challenges facing mainline Protestant churches. He explores the idea that the crisis may stem from a lack of faith rather than mere decline. The discussion covers the importance of experiencing God's presence, reimagining church vitality beyond numbers, and the power of storytelling in fostering community. Root advocates for deeper spiritual connections and authentic experiences, providing hope for congregations navigating post-COVID challenges.
The current crisis in mainline Protestant churches emphasizes a deeper spiritual connection with God over mere numerical growth and revitalization strategies.
Storytelling is essential for fostering community and deepening relationships within congregations, as personal narratives illustrate God's work and enhance connections among members.
A shift from striving for relevance to seeking resonance encourages churches to focus on authentic experiences and genuine relationships for spiritual growth.
Deep dives
Understanding the Crisis of Faith
Many mainline Protestant churches are experiencing a crisis of faith, particularly in the wake of the COVID-19 pandemic, which has exacerbated existing declines in membership and engagement. Pastors are grappling with these challenges, seeking new strategies for revitalization while often feeling overwhelmed by the pressure to attract more attendees. The discussion highlights a need for congregations to shift their focus from numerical growth to a deeper spiritual connection with God and their communities. This shift involves embracing a slower, more contemplative approach to faith, prioritizing worship, prayer, and study over flashy, modern initiatives.
The Role of God in Decline
The crisis facing many churches may not solely be about numerical decline but rather a crisis in faith and awareness of God’s presence. Recognizing that God is active in history allows congregations to engage with their communities meaningfully rather than succumbing to the pressures of relevance and status. Emphasizing a relationship with God and waiting for divine guidance can lead to spiritual renewal, rather than relying solely on practical strategies. This perspective encourages churches to be receptive to God's movement rather than viewing decline strictly through the lens of dwindling resources.
Emphasizing Storytelling in Ministry
Storytelling plays a crucial role in the life of congregations, as narratives reshape identities and foster deeper connections among members. Churches need to create spaces for sharing personal stories, which can deepen relationships and enhance communal bonds. The power of stories can illustrate God's work in the world and provide a counter to feelings of isolation or disconnection within faith communities. By highlighting individual experiences, congregations can create a richer tapestry of faith, enabling members to bear witness to God’s presence collectively.
The Difference Between Relevance and Resonance
The conversation draws a distinction between striving for relevance in a competitive religious landscape and seeking resonance—a deeper, more relational engagement with spirituality. Relevance often emphasizes numerical success and marketability, while resonance focuses on authentic experiences of connection and community. This shift toward resonance involves slowing down, engaging in meaningful practices, and fostering genuine relationships that allow for spiritual growth. By prioritizing resonance, churches can cultivate a sense of belonging and purpose that transcends mere attendance numbers.
A Word of Hope Amid Uncertainty
In a time of uncertainty, the reminder that the church is ultimately God's responsibility provides comfort and hope for congregations. Historical examples illustrate that declines in church membership do not spell the end for Christianity; rather, they can pave the way for revival. The ongoing commitment to faith and community can endure through challenging periods, and the assurance that God remains present encourages pastors and congregants alike. Believers are called to embrace their collective journey of faith, trusting in God’s faithfulness, even amid trials and transitions.
If you’re the pastor or leader of a mainline Protestant congregation you have heard about your declining congregation for years if not decades. You probably even lead a congregation that wonders if its best days are behind them.
Denominations, specialists and others have some idea on how to help your congregation get back on the path towards growth. We want to try anything that can solve this crisis of decline.
But what if the crisis is not about decline but about something deeper? What if it is a crisis not of decline, but of faith in the God who is God?
Today, I talk with Dr. Andrew Root, the Carrie Olson Baalson Professor of Youth and Family Ministry at Luther Seminary in St. Paul, MN about churches in decline, the loss of life, and how revival can only come when we are open to the presence of God.
This podcast is a labor of love. It’s free to everyone, but there are costs associated with making this podcast available. Would you consider becoming a paid subscriber? It’s $5/month or $60/year. Thanks!