Why Did We Really Abandon the Aether? - Dr. Adam Forrest Kay, DemystifySci #333

30 snips

Apr 6, 2025

Adam Forrest Kay, author of 'Escape From Shadow Physics', explores the paradoxes of quantum mechanics through the lens of hydrodynamic quantum analogs. He argues that classical systems may challenge our understanding of quantum intuition. The conversation dives into the mechanics of droplets bouncing on surfaces and their surprising similarities to quantum behavior. Kay also discusses the historical shift from aether theories to modern physics, shedding light on the skepticism and philosophical debates that have shaped scientific thought.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

Unplanned Physics

Adam Kay's interest in quantum physics arose unexpectedly after a period of focusing on neuroscience and meaning.
This shift, inspired by the book "Greatness Cannot Be Planned," led him to explore intuitions about oscillating patterns in physics.

INSIGHT

Hydrodynamic Quantum Analog

The hydrodynamic quantum analog involves oil droplets bouncing on a vibrating fluid bath, mimicking quantum behavior.
Researchers Yves Couder and Emmanuel Fort discovered this phenomenon, noticing the droplets' wave-particle duality.

ANECDOTE

Double-Slit Controversy

Early hydrodynamic quantum analog experiments, like the double-slit experiment, faced reproducibility issues.
Despite this, the analog's ability to exhibit classical systems mimicking quantum math remains significant.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

The Born-Einstein letters

Max Born

Albert Einstein

This book comprises a 40-year correspondence between Albert Einstein and Max Born, along with contributions from Born's wife Hedwig. The letters span two world wars and cover a wide range of topics including debates on quantum mechanics, personal reflections on their families and lives, and discussions about the tumultuous political climate of their time. Despite their scientific disagreements, particularly on the interpretation of quantum mechanics, the letters highlight the enduring friendship and mutual respect between Einstein and the Borns. The correspondence also touches on their shared love of music, their efforts to help refugee scientists, and their differing views on Germany during and after World War II.

Quantum Dialogues

null

Mara Beller

Escape from Shadow Physics

Adam Forrest Kay

Adam Forrest Kay's "Escape from Shadow Physics" delves into the historical narrative of quantum mechanics, challenging the prevailing view that reality is fundamentally intangible and mathematical. The book traces humanity's journey from studying atoms to grappling with their probabilistic nature. Kay explores various interpretations and analogies, including hydrodynamic quantum analogs, to offer a fresh perspective on the quantum world. He questions the prevailing positivistic approach, arguing for a deeper, more material understanding of quantum phenomena. The book encourages readers to reconsider the limitations of human comprehension in understanding the universe.

How the hippies saved physics

David Kaiser

The Tao of Physics

Fritjof Capra

In 'The Tao of Physics', Fritjof Capra delves into the striking similarities between the worldviews of modern physics and those of Eastern mystical traditions such as Hinduism, Buddhism, and Taoism. The book discusses how both modern physics and Eastern mysticism describe the world as an interconnected, dynamic system, and how concepts like the unity of all things, the cyclical nature of change, and the illusory nature of separate entities are common to both. Capra argues that these parallels offer a deeper understanding of the nature of reality and the human place within it. The book has been widely read and has influenced discussions on the integration of science and spirituality.

Albert Einstein, philosopher-scientist

Albert Einstein

Why greatness cannot be planned

Kenneth Stanley