The Herd with Colin Cowherd THE HERD - Hour 3 - Aaron Boone's managing style, relying on analytics, the MLB Wild Card round, Ian O'Connor
Oct 2, 2025
In this conversation, guest Ian O'Connor, a veteran sports journalist from The Athletic, tackles the scrutiny faced by Yankees manager Aaron Boone after a playoff loss. They explore the pitfalls of relying too heavily on analytics in decision-making, contrasting it with traditional managerial instincts. Ian critiques the controversial pull of pitcher Max Fried, viewing it as a managerial misstep. The duo also dives into team dynamics and player expectations as the Yankees navigate the postseason, alongside broader discussions about coaching styles in sports.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Boone Protects Players Over Image
- Ian O'Connor recounts asking Aaron Boone why he absorbed criticism for removing Garrett Cole in the World Series.
- Boone said protecting players and winning mattered more than saving face.
Analytics Can Strip Managerial Discretion
- Colin argues analytics shouldn't override obvious game-changing pitcher matchups like Garrett Crochet.
- He warns analytics can remove managerial control in decisive moments.
Continuity Over Constant Change
- Ian says the Yankees value continuity and prefer long-tenured managers as part of a stable program.
- That stability can deliver consistent playoff appearances even without recent championships.
