The Herd with Colin Cowherd 3 & Out - Who should be the MVP, What's going on in GB, Belichick to the Giants?
Nov 12, 2025
NFL MVP discussions heat up as various candidates are evaluated, with a special focus on Drake Maye. Green Bay's coaching challenges come under scrutiny, questioning playcalling and personnel fit. A look into the potential hiring landscape reveals debates over Bill Belichick's future and those who may replace Sean McDermott. The Eagles' playoff prospects are examined, alongside the frustrations of Packers and Steelers fans as they face roster issues.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
MVP Bias Toward Quarterbacks
- John places Drake Maye among MVP contenders but says quarterback-centric voting likely favors others.
- He argues Jonathan Taylor would win a non-QB 'Heisman' and deserves MVP recognition for dominance.
Pick Reliable Production Over Low Averages
- When choosing between consistent yardage and low-per-carry gains, prefer reliability and consistent production.
- A back who gives 100 yards per game is far more valuable than one averaging two yards per carry.
Personal Military Ties And Support
- John recounts family military service and his support for Folds of Honor after their president appeared on the podcast.
- He emphasizes personal gratitude for veterans and plans to teach his son the same respect.