Room for Nuance The Baptist vs. Presbyterian Interview
Sep 25, 2025
In this lively discussion, Nathan White, pastor of Good Shepherd Presbyterian Church, dives into the theological nuances between Baptist and Presbyterian traditions. He shares his journey from a Baptist background to embracing infant baptism, emphasizing covenantal continuity. The conversation explores baptism’s role, covenant theology, and how both traditions can find common ground. Nathan also highlights the importance of historical context and practical fellowship despite differences, all while maintaining a spirit of camaraderie and respect.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
From Baptist Youth Pastor To Presbyterian
- Nathan White recounts growing up Baptist, being baptized as a child, and serving in various Baptist ministries before shifting to Presbyterianism.
- He describes his youth internships, ordination as a Baptist youth pastor, and eventual move into Reformed Baptist and PCA ministry.
Hold Convictions To Sharpen Friends
- Maintain firm convictions to enable candid, loving theological conversation with fellow Christians.
- Strong, secure beliefs free you to sharpen others without insecurity undermining fellowship.
The Night Sean Got Choked Up
- Nathan recalls Sean getting choked up while trying to persuade him, showing their deep friendship amid theological debate.
- Both men treasure that memory as a defining moment of loving disagreement.
