Ever wondered what it looks like to get feedback from an editor?
Recently, my friend Kim Kessler, herself a developmental editor and author, sent me a scene of the novel she’s working on. I read it and prepared some notes for her.
Then, we hopped on a call to talk through my feedback.
And we recorded the whole conversation!
In this episode, you’ll hear exactly how developmental editing works. I walk Kim through the same process I use for all my editing clients.
You’ll hear the questions I ask her, the specific recommendations I give, and my favorite part: the moment of epiphany, when we “solve” what she needs to do next with her scene.
And if you ever feel nervous about working with an editor . . . well, we get it. Kim and I share why we felt nervous about this episode, too—and why this editing session was worth all the nerves and risk!
Fair warning: this episode is long.
It’s worth listening to the whole thing, especially if you want to hear exactly what a real developmental editing session looks like.
But if you’d like to jump straight to some key moments, check out these time stamps:
[5:42] Why Kim and I don’t offer sample edits of developmental editing
[10:06] Kim introduces her novel and shares the context of her scene
[18:35] The most important editing question: WHY Kim is writing this novel and what she wants it to achieve
[25:40] What I love about Kim’s scene and what she’s doing well
[29:47] The start of our scene analysis—if you’ve listened to the episode “5 Essential Questions to Fix Boring Scenes,” these questions will be familiar to you
[36:22] What changes in this scene? What’s the value shift?
[54:31] What is this scene really about?
[1:02:45] The specific recommendation I have for Kim’s scene
[1:04:57] Kim and I brainstorm ways to apply that feedback
And if you’d like this kind of feedback on your scenes . . .
. . . keep your eye out for a way to sign up for a scene critique of your own, coming soon!
Links mentioned in the episode:
Send me a Text Message!
Want my support in your revision?
In Story Clarity, we’ll work one-on-one to sharpen your story’s structure and craft a revision plan that works. If you’re ready for thoughtful, personalized feedback from an editor who gets what you’re trying to do, I’d love to hear what you’re working on.
Get started by telling me about your story here.
Support the show
Rate, Review, & Follow on Apple Podcasts
"I love Alice and Your Next Draft." If that sounds like you, please consider rating and reviewing my show! This helps me support more writers through the mess—and joy—of the editing process. Click here, scroll to the bottom, tap the stars to rate, and select “Write a Review.” Then be sure to let me know what you loved most about the episode!
Loving the show? Show your support with a monthly contribution »
Your Next Draft