Classic Debate: Ian Fleming vs John le Carré

5 snips

Apr 5, 2025

In this thrilling conversation, David Farr, a talented screenwriter known for adapting John le Carré's works, champions the gritty realism of le Carré against Ian Fleming's glamorous James Bond. They dive into the contrasting styles of these literary giants, discussing how Fleming's high-octane adventures shape popular culture while le Carré exposes the moral ambiguities of espionage. Actors bring both authors' narratives to life, highlighting unforgettable moments and the deeper emotional landscapes that define the world of spies. This lively debate illuminates what makes each author unique.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

ANECDOTE

Horowitz's Introduction to Fleming

Anthony Horowitz's mother gave him Dr. No when he was 10.
The book offered escape from his unpleasant prep school and shaped his life.

ANECDOTE

Farr's Introduction to le Carré

David Farr's father introduced him to John le Carré's work.
He watched Smiley's People at age 12 and became obsessed with the books.

INSIGHT

Bond's Appeal

Ian Fleming's James Bond offered a unique blend of warmth, passion, and fun, contrasting with the darker world of le Carré.
Bond's widespread popularity is evident in the films' global reach and cultural impact.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

1984

None

George Orwell

Published in 1949, '1984' is a cautionary tale by George Orwell that explores the dangers of totalitarianism. The novel is set in a dystopian future where the world is divided into three super-states, with the protagonist Winston Smith living in Oceania, ruled by the mysterious and omnipotent leader Big Brother. Winston works at the Ministry of Truth, where he rewrites historical records to conform to the Party's ever-changing narrative. He begins an illicit love affair with Julia and starts to rebel against the Party, but they are eventually caught and subjected to brutal torture and indoctrination. The novel highlights themes of government surveillance, manipulation of language and history, and the suppression of individual freedom and independent thought.

Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy

John Le Carré

In this novel, George Smiley is summoned from retirement to investigate a mole within the British intelligence service, known as the Circus. The story unfolds as a cat-and-mouse game, with Smiley delving into the pasts of his suspects, each codenamed from a children’s nursery rhyme: Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, and Sailor. The investigation is complex, involving office politics, personal betrayals, and the moral ambiguities of the espionage world. Le Carré masterfully crafts a realistic and gripping narrative that critiques the espionage industry and its impact on individuals and society[1][3][5].

James Bond

Ian Fleming

Alex Rider

Anthony Horowitz

In 'Stormbreaker,' Alex Rider learns that his uncle, Ian Rider, was a spy and not just a banker. He is recruited by MI6 to investigate the death of his uncle and uncover a plot by the villainous Herod Sayle to use a new computer system to destroy London.

Casino Royale

Ian Fleming

In *Casino Royale*, Ian Fleming introduces James Bond, a suave and supercompetent British spy. Bond is dispatched to the French casino town of Royale-les-Eaux to bankrupt Le Chiffre, a ruthless Russian agent who has embezzled Soviet funds. The mission involves a high-stakes game of baccarat, and if Bond succeeds, Le Chiffre will likely be executed by his Soviet paymasters. The novel also delves into Bond's relationship with Vesper Lynd, a mysterious and beautiful agent, and features elements of espionage, torture, and a bitter twist at the end. The book is known for its vivid descriptions of the casino scenes, Bond's introspective nature, and the philosophical discussions on good and evil[1][3][4].

A Private Spy

John Le Carré

A Private Spy is a comprehensive collection of John le Carré's letters, spanning seven decades and providing a personal and historical perspective on his life and work. The book includes correspondence with notable figures such as Alec Guinness and offers a glimpse into le Carré's thoughts on politics, literature, and personal relationships.

The Night Manager

John Le Carré

The Night Manager is John le Carré's first post-Cold War novel, detailing an undercover operation to take down Richard Onslow Roper, a billionaire arms and drug trafficker. Jonathan Pine, a former British soldier and night manager at a luxury hotel, seeks revenge against Roper for past injustices. Pine infiltrates Roper's organization, navigating a complex web of espionage and corruption within intelligence agencies.

Dr. No

Ian Fleming

In 'Dr. No,' James Bond is sent to Jamaica to investigate the disappearance of the local British agent, John Strangways, and his assistant. Bond soon discovers that the disappearance is linked to Dr. Julius No, a reclusive megalomaniac with steel pincers for hands, who is working with the Russians to sabotage US test missiles launched from Cape Canaveral. Bond must navigate through an obstacle course designed by Dr. No, face various deadly challenges, and ultimately confront a giant squid. The novel is known for its blend of action, espionage, and the iconic villainy of Dr. No, who is one of the most memorable characters in the series.

Trigger Mortis

Anthony Horowitz

Trigger Mortis is a James Bond novel written by Anthony Horowitz, set in 1957, two weeks after the events of 'Goldfinger'. The story involves Bond's mission to protect a British race car driver from a Soviet plot and delves into the early space race. The novel features previously unpublished material by Ian Fleming and includes familiar characters such as Pussy Galore, M, and Miss Moneypenny. It is praised for its authentic recreation of the golden age of Bond, with elements of speed, danger, strong women, and fiendish villains[1][3][4].

A Perfect Spy

null

George Orwell

John le Carre's "A Perfect Spy" delves into the complex world of espionage through the eyes of Magnus Pym, a spy whose life is a carefully constructed deception. The novel explores themes of betrayal, identity, and the moral ambiguities inherent in the spy game. Pym's intricate web of lies and manipulations unravels as he confronts his past and the consequences of his actions. Le Carre masterfully portrays the psychological toll of espionage, highlighting the human cost of deception and the struggle for self-preservation. The novel's intricate plot and compelling characters make it a standout in the spy fiction genre.

Goldfinger

Ian Fleming

In 'Goldfinger', James Bond delves into the world of Auric Goldfinger, a wealthy man obsessed with gold, who is suspected of being connected to SMERSH. As Bond investigates Goldfinger's activities, he discovers a massive plot to rob Fort Knox, leading to a thrilling adventure filled with espionage and danger. The novel explores themes of greed, power, and the complexities of Bond's character.

The Spy Who Came In From The Cold

John Le Carré

The Spy Who Came in from the Cold is a gripping Cold War novel by John le Carré, focusing on Alec Leamas, a British intelligence officer tasked with a final mission before retirement. Leamas is sent to East Germany as a faux defector to sow disinformation about Hans-Dieter Mundt, a powerful East German intelligence officer. The novel explores themes of espionage, loyalty, and the moral complexities of spy work during the Cold War era.

From Russia with Love

Ian Fleming

In this fifth James Bond novel, Ian Fleming crafts a tale of espionage and intrigue. The story revolves around SMERSH's plan to assassinate Bond and discredit British Intelligence by using Corporal Tatiana Romanova, a Soviet cipher clerk, as bait. Romanova is instructed to pretend to defect to the British, offering them the Spektor decoding machine. Bond, sent to Istanbul to collect Romanova and the Spektor, navigates a complex web of Soviet agents, including the deadly Red Grant. The plot unfolds against the backdrop of Istanbul and the Orient Express, culminating in a tense confrontation that tests Bond's survival skills and loyalty.

Mission Song

John Le Carré

The Mission Song follows Bruno Salvador, a skilled interpreter with a complex background, as he becomes embroiled in a secret conference between Congolese warlords and Western interests. The novel explores themes of exploitation, geopolitics, and personal identity. Bruno's journey from naivety to awareness of Western hypocrisy is central to the story.

The constant gardener

John Le Carré

The Constant Gardener, written by John le Carré, follows Justin Quayle, a British diplomat in Nairobi, Kenya, as he investigates the murder of his wife Tessa. Tessa, an activist, had been uncovering a corporate scandal involving a pharmaceutical company, KVH, which was conducting unethical medical experiments in Africa. Justin's investigation reveals a complex conspiracy involving corrupt bureaucracy, pharmaceutical money, and international deceit. As he delves deeper, he faces numerous dangers and uncovers a trail of corruption that reaches into the highest levels of the British Foreign Office and beyond.

The Secret Heart

John le Carré: An Intimate Memoir

Suleika Dawson

The Secret Heart is a candid and insightful account of Suleika Dawson's unique and enduring love affair with the renowned author John le Carré. The book offers a personal perspective on le Carré's life, written with honesty and humor.

Smiley's people

John Le Carré

John le Carré's 'Smiley's People' is a gripping espionage novel that continues the story of George Smiley, the iconic spymaster. The novel follows Smiley's pursuit of Karla, his longtime nemesis, in a climactic confrontation that tests his skills and resolve. Le Carré masterfully weaves together political intrigue, personal relationships, and moral dilemmas, creating a complex and suspenseful narrative. The novel explores themes of betrayal, loyalty, and the human cost of espionage. 'Smiley's People' is a powerful and moving conclusion to the Smiley saga, leaving a lasting impression on readers.

The House of Silk

Anthony Horowitz

The House of Silk is a Sherlock Holmes novel that delves into a complex case involving an international conspiracy linked to the mysterious 'House of Silk'. The story unfolds with Holmes and Watson navigating through the criminal underworlds of London and Boston, uncovering shocking truths. The novel is praised for its authentic portrayal of the Holmes era while introducing modern elements.

Moriarty

Anthony Horowitz

Moriarty by Anthony Horowitz is a detective fiction novel that delves into the world of Sherlock Holmes after the legendary confrontation at Reichenbach Falls. The story follows detectives Frederick Chase and Athelney Jones as they navigate London's criminal underworld to prevent a new mastermind from taking Moriarty's place. The novel is filled with twists, suspense, and intrigue, offering a fresh yet authentic take on the Sherlock Holmes universe.

Call for the Dead

John Le Carré

In 'Call for the Dead', John le Carré introduces George Smiley, a shrewd but unassuming intelligence agent. The story begins with the apparent suicide of Samuel Fennan, a Foreign Office civil servant, following a routine security check by Smiley. As Smiley delves deeper, he uncovers inconsistencies suggesting murder rather than suicide, leading him into a complex world of espionage and betrayal. The novel is more of a detective story than a spy thriller, offering a gripping exploration of moral ambiguity and deception.

They are the titans of the spy novel, who have elevated thrillers to the level of literary fiction. Much imitated, much adapted by the big and small screens, Ian Fleming and John Le Carré have painted our picture of post-war espionage: Fleming through the dashing figure of James Bond, with his lush locations and Martinis as icy as his heart; Le Carré through his damning portrait of the British secret service drawn from his own time in MI5 and MI6.

But which of the two novelists is the greater? In this thrilling contest, Fleming’s case was made by Anthony Horowitz, creator of the bestselling Alex Rider spy novels and author of the official Bond continuation novel Trigger Mortis.

Championing Le Carré – whose memoir about his life as a former spy currently sits in the bestseller lists – was David Farr, Emmy-nominated screenwriter of the BBC’s adaptation of The Night Manager.

Actors Lesley Manville, Simon Callow, Matthew Lewis and Alex Macqueen joined us to bring both authors' works to life along with our host, author and critic Erica Wagner.

----

If you'd like to become a Member and get access to all our full ad free conversations, plus all of our Members-only content, just visit intelligencesquared.com/membership to find out more.

For £4.99 per month you'll also receive:

- Full-length and ad-free Intelligence Squared episodes, wherever you get your podcasts

- Bonus Intelligence Squared podcasts, curated feeds and members exclusive series

- 15% discount on livestreams and in-person tickets for all Intelligence Squared events

...

Or Subscribe on Apple for £4.99:

- Full-length and ad-free Intelligence Squared podcasts

- Bonus Intelligence Squared podcasts, curated feeds and members exclusive series

…

Already a subscriber? Thank you for supporting our mission to foster honest debate and compelling conversations! Visit intelligencesquared.com to explore all your benefits including ad-free podcasts, exclusive bonus content and early access.

…

Subscribe to our newsletter here to hear about our latest events, discounts and much more.

https://www.intelligencesquared.com/newsletter-signup/

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices