360 |Holes in the Standard Islamic Narrative(SIN), with Guest Speakers, Pt3
Mar 19, 2022
auto_awesome
Panelists discuss the lack of historical criticism on the Quran, the absence of biblical support for Abraham's stations in Hijaz, the Quran's relationship to other books like the Torah, and the historical narrative of the Quran in a 7th century sectarian environment.
The Quran lacks historical criticism and may have significant influences from other religious texts like the Torah.
The geographical positioning of Abraham's stations in Hijaz without Biblical support raises questions about the standard Islamic narrative.
Deep dives
Research on the Historical Critique of Islam
The podcast delves into a detailed discussion on the historical critique of Islam by introducing the 'sin sifters.' These panelists aim to analyze and challenge the standard Islamic narrative, highlighting discrepancies and exploring alternative explanations. Through thorough research, they uncover connections between Aramaic Christian traditions, early Christianity, and influences on the Quran, presenting a comprehensive and cohesive historical puzzle.
Comparison with Biblical Historical Criticism
The podcast participants discuss the application of biblical historical criticism methodologies to Islam, emphasizing the need for a similar critical approach in Islamic studies. By drawing parallels with studies on the Bible, the podcast highlights the significance of historical criticism in unraveling the origins and development of religious texts. The exploration of historical contexts and textual analyses opens new avenues for understanding the Quran within a broader Judeo-Christian framework.
Exploration of Geographic and Cultural Influences
The podcast examines geographic and cultural factors shaping early Islamic narratives, focusing on the possible origins of Islam in the northern regions rather than the traditional southern view. Insights are shared regarding the presence of Aramaic traditions, Hebrew influences, and the development of the Arabic script. Participants highlight the significance of interactions with Jewish and Christian communities, shedding light on the contextual backdrop for the emergence of Islam.
Al Fadi continues his discussion with the Panelists: 1. Thomas is working on a book to summarize 20 years of research. He also says the Quran has not gone through a historical criticism . 2. Mel thinks that the most damaging findings of the SIN is the stations of Abraham being in Hijaz, It has no Biblical support. 3. Murad says the Bible is history, and if the Kaaba is in Mecca why haven't the Jews lay any claim to it? 4. Oden says that there is no evidence that the Quran is an Islamic text, rather it is a product of other books mainly the Torah. 5. Paul says that the Quran was not supposed to be recited alone, but with other books(ie; OT, NT). 6. Jay says that the Quran is a historical narrative of a 7th century environment of sectarian groups waiting for Jesus' return.