Catholic Answers Live #12343 Did Christ Have to Die for Mary, Marian Dogmas, and Grace? - Karlo Broussard
Aug 26, 2025
Karlo Broussard, a renowned apologist and author, dives deep into the provocative question of whether Christ had to die for Mary. He explores intriguing topics like Mary’s parents' knowledge of her pregnancy and challenges to Marian dogmas. The conversation touches upon the significance of Mary being 'full of grace' compared to Stephen and clarifies the essential roles Marian beliefs play in relation to the Gospel message. Broussard also addresses Protestant views, making for a compelling and thought-provoking dialogue.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Different Greek Words Matter
- The Greek terms differ: Stephen is pleres charitos (present grace), Mary is kekarismene (a perfected, resulting state).
- Luke 1:28 points toward Mary’s permanent fullness of grace but does not by itself prove immaculate conception.
Don't Overclaim Luke 1:28
- Avoid overplaying Luke 1:28 as definitive proof for immaculate conception when arguing with Protestants.
- Use it as supportive evidence alongside typology and tradition instead.
Luke 1:28 As Part Of A Cumulative Case
- Luke 1:28 creates a theological trajectory rather than a standalone proof for the Immaculate Conception.
- Combined with typology (Mary as new Eve, ark imagery) it strengthens a cumulative biblical case.
