Asha Rangappa, a former FBI special agent and legal contributor for ABC News, shares her insights on the state of law enforcement integrity. She discusses troubling incidents such as the recent firings at the Pentagon and questionable appointments within the FBI. Asha warns about the dangers of individuals in power who manipulate the law for their own ends. The conversation also highlights the radicalization in the military and the alarming role of private security in democratic spaces, raising critical questions about authority and accountability.
The podcast discusses the growing concern that individuals in power may exploit the law to undermine democracy and civil rights.
It highlights the unsettling trend of politicization and lack of transparency within law enforcement agencies, eroding public trust in these institutions.
Deep dives
The Threat of Authoritarianism
Concerns have arisen regarding the erosion of democratic institutions and the rule of law in the U.S. The use of legal frameworks to suppress dissent and consolidate power poses a significant threat to democracy. Actions such as the halting of foreign aid funds demonstrate a clash between the presidential administration and the judiciary, raising questions about the balance of power. The ongoing political climate reflects a concerning trend where defenders of the law may become its adversaries.
Radical Changes in Law Enforcement
The podcast highlights alarming developments within law enforcement, marked by the appointment of officials lacking traditional qualifications and experience. The new leadership at the FBI, including figures like Dan Bongino, raises doubts about the agency's future direction and integrity. Bipartisan concerns about politicization and radical reforming of law enforcement practices suggest an unsettling shift that may undermine public trust. The emphasis on loyalty over competency could lead to a radical transformation detrimental to the agency's fundamental mission.
Implications for National Security
A notable shift is occurring in government agencies concerning national security and military engagement, raising alarms about potential legal violations. The dismissal of key military leaders and the undermining of diversity initiatives could weaken efforts to prevent radicalization within the armed forces. The purging of military lawyers, known as JAG officers, may embolden illegal orders, jeopardizing the rule of law. These worrying trends signal a move toward greater authoritarian control and decreased accountability in critical governmental functions.
The Importance of Accountability in Governance
Obscured accountability within government actions is becoming a disturbing trend, impacting citizens' trust and safety. The incident involving unidentified security forces illustrates the complications that arise when individuals acting under state authority are unidentifiable. This lack of transparency erodes public confidence and encourages a chilling effect on free speech and civil rights. Strengthening accountability and demanding clarity in governance remains crucial to countering authoritarian practices and safeguarding democratic principles.
This past week has seen firings at the Pentagon, an Executive Order targeting a private law firm, the installation of a podcaster and January 6 denialist as #2 at the FBI, and an incident in which an audience member at an Idaho townhall was wrestled to the ground and led away in zip ties by private security that answer to no lawful police entity. Is this what happens when the lawyers, police officers, military officials and other law enforcement organizations who are meant to keep us all safe, are sidelined or conscripted into lawless behavior?
On this week’s episode of Amicus, Dahlia Lithwick speaks to Asha Rangappa, a former FBI special agent, editor at Just Security and author of the substack The Freedom Academy with Asha Rangappa. Asha explains what happens when people who are hellbent on using the law to break the law achieve positions of power, and whether the safeguards still in place can hold.
Want more Amicus? Join Slate Plus to unlock weekly bonus episodes with exclusive legal analysis. Plus, you’ll access ad-free listening across all your favorite Slate podcasts. You can subscribe directly from the Amicus show page on Apple Podcasts and Spotify. Or, visit slate.com/amicusplus to get access wherever you listen.