Ryan and Todd analyze Machiavelli's The Prince and its influence on later political thinkers. They discuss Machiavelli's novelty and limitations, the relevance of his ideas in modern politics, the non-existence of the Other and the People in his work, his perspective on reading texts, and the concept of unthinkable ideas and winning decisively. They also touch on actor performances in movies, the question of Machiavelli's thesis, and the limitations of contemporary politics.
Machiavelli's thinking emphasizes stability and placation, neglecting the transformative aspects of contemporary political discourse.
Machiavelli's focus on power and stability limits his thinking, excluding the possibility of doing the impossible or attempting transformative change.
Machiavelli's political perspective lacks dialectical elements, disregarding the role of contradiction and enjoyment in transformative politics.
Deep dives
The Limits of Machiavelli's Political Thinking
Machiavelli's political thinking focuses on stability and placation rather than transformative ideals. He emphasizes the importance of fear and love as emotions that contribute to stability in a state. However, Machiavelli lacks a sense of contradiction and enjoyment, which are important in contemporary political discourse. His ideas are more aligned with a conservative approach, seeking stability rather than transformative change. Machiavelli's thinking is limited because he doesn't consider the possibility of transcendence or the role of the unconscious in politics.
The Paranoia and Structural Steps of Machiavelli's Political Thinking
Machiavelli's thinking revolves around the idea of placation and the necessity of taking structural steps to maintain stability in a state. He recommends leaders to be constantly paranoid and take measures to prevent attacks or revolts. Machiavelli's emphasis on power and the absence of an articulation of an ideal limit his thinking. He does not consider the possibility of doing the impossible or attempting the transformative, which is an important aspect of contemporary political discourse.
The Incompatibility of Machiavelli's Thinking with Dialectics
Machiavelli's political thinking lacks dialectical elements, leading to an exclusion of contradictory and enjoyment in political discourse. He idealizes stability and focuses on maintaining power rather than considering the complexities of collective formation and the role of contradiction in transformative politics. Films like 'The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance' and 'Lincoln' explore the idea of doing the impossible to create stability, which goes beyond Machiavelli's framework. Machiavelli's thinking is more aligned with a conservative approach, emphasizing the need for stability but neglecting the possibility of transcendence and the unconscious in political analysis.
Machiavelli's Paranoia and Conspiratorial Worldview
Machiavelli writes his famous work in response to being jailed for being part of a conspiracy, which reflects his deep connection to a conspiratorial world. He is aware of the presence of conspiracies everywhere and believes it's accurate to think so. However, he falls into paranoia while thinking about those conspiracies, which limits his perspective and hinders his ability to see beyond the web of conspiracy.
Machiavelli's Focus on Power and Stability
Machiavelli's political outlook emphasizes the importance of stability and the consolidation of power. He acknowledged the significance of compromising and placating the desires of different societal factions, such as the aristocracy. His approach is rooted in a base-superstructure model, where politics supersedes religion and the leader plays a symbolic role in maintaining stability. However, he fails to recognize the dialectical nature of power dynamics and the contradictory nature of the people, which limits his ability to fully grasp and analyze political complexities.
Ryan and Todd analyze Machiavelli's The Prince by tracing its influence on later political thinkers, including Hegel, Gramsci, and Althusser. They discuss Machiavelli's novelty and his limitations as a thinker of the political act.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
