Existentialist Philosophy, Politics, & Theology with Paul Capetz
Apr 13, 2012
auto_awesome
Join Professor Paul Capetz, an expert in existentialist philosophy and theology, alongside Deacon Stephen Keating, as they dive into a whirlwind of ideas! They discuss how existentialism influences modern theology, with insights on Kierkegaard and Heidegger's takes on individual identity. Political critiques emerge, connecting Tillich's thoughts to contemporary American issues. They also explore the intersection of addiction recovery and spirituality, emphasizing the need for authentic faith amidst societal pressures. It’s a captivating conversation for philosophy buffs!
Existentialism arose from European disillusionment post-World Wars, challenging conventional rationality and seeking individual meaning amidst chaos.
The philosophy is not solely atheistic, as it encompasses both atheistic and religious interpretations, examining existential angst across different beliefs.
Kierkegaard's existentialism highlights personal commitment to faith and ethical decision-making, urging individuals to embrace authenticity over societal norms.
Deep dives
Origins of Existentialism
Existentialism emerged as a response to the disillusionment faced by Europe following the World Wars, particularly World War I. It arose from an environment where the once optimistic belief in progress and rationality was shattered, leading thinkers, such as Kierkegaard, Nietzsche, and Dostoevsky, to articulate their concerns about meaning and existence. These figures challenged the dominant philosophies of their time, rejecting the belief that history follows a rational progression. Existentialism, therefore, encompasses both a critique of modern thought and a quest for individual meaning amidst the chaos.
Atheistic vs. Religious Existentialism
Existentialism is not inherently atheistic, as it can be subdivided into atheistic and religious forms. While philosophers like Nietzsche and Sartre represent atheistic existentialism, religious interpretations arise from figures such as Kierkegaard, Tillich, and Bultmann. The core concern across both strands is the existential angst experienced by individuals in contemplating their existence, meaning, and the weight of choice. This recognition allows for a nuanced understanding where existentialism can engage with faith and the search for ultimate meaning, regardless of religious affiliations.
The Role of Individual Decision
Central to existentialist thought is the idea that existence precedes essence, emphasizing the importance of personal decision-making in defining one's life. Sartre illustrates this concept through the story of a young man in Nazi-occupied France, highlighting the burden of freedom and the necessity of making responsible choices. Kierkegaard adds depth with the notion that true individuality comes from rejecting societal norms and aligning one’s life with authentic beliefs, even in the face of overwhelming cultural pressures. This focus on individual responsibility challenges people to critically assess their choices rather than conform blindly to the expectations of society.
Kierkegaard's Perspective on Faith
Kierkegaard's existentialism uniquely intertwines with Christian faith by illustrating the leap required to pursue an authentic relationship with God. He posits that true faith often comes in moments of extreme ethical challenge, as exemplified by the biblical story of Abraham, called to sacrifice his son Isaac. This narrative serves to emphasize the necessity of personal commitment to faith over mere adherence to societal norms. Hence, Kierkegaard's work challenges believers to embrace their individuality and make profound ethical decisions rather than rely solely on traditions or collective beliefs.
Tillich and Culture's Impact on Faith
Paul Tillich's existentialism engages deeply with the notions of culture, existential threats, and the quest for ultimate concern. He posits that religious concerns stem from human beings' struggles with being versus non-being, where God represents the ultimate power affirming our existence. Tillich seeks to integrate Marxist critiques with biblical prophetic traditions, ultimately asserting that faith must challenge the status quo rather than align with it. This perspective enables an exploration of how contemporary cultural crises—like the rise of authoritarianism—reflect existential fears, prompting a call for responsive and radical faith to address these pressing issues.
Søren Kierkegaard, Friedrich Nietzsche, Martin Heidegger, Fyodor Dostoyevsky, Jean-Paul Sartre, Karl Barth, & Paul Tillich all make an appearance in this podcast. So sit back and get ready for a nerd-filled fiesta! Prof. Paul Capetz & Deacon Stephen Keating join Bo and I in the Homebrewed Christianity HQ in Redondo Beach on a rainy St. Patrick's Day morning for a podcast. We had a blast! You will enjoy this podcast...if you are into philosophy, history, political ranting, Tillich's theology or existentialism hitting the pews then this is the podcast for you. Paul is an amazing historical theologian, Presbyterian minister, my favorite Calvinist, and dear friend. He was on the podcast for Calvin's 500th birthday, joined John Cobb for our special 101st episode, and explained how a Calvinist gets pumped about Process Theology. THANK YOU..."Secret Deacon" who had JR Cigars deliver some yummy sticks to me. That was awesome. I love it when the Deacons call in and I love it when they donate on PayPal but this 'secret deacon' invented a new form of encouragement - mailing me GOOD cigars. To whomever sent them THANKS A MILLION!
