
Critical Readings CR Episode 300: Romeo and Juliet, Part II
Dec 8, 2025
The hosts dive into the intriguing second act of Romeo and Juliet, highlighting the impulsive romance and the enabling figures surrounding the young lovers. They explore the dark humor of Mercutio and the warning inherent in the prologue. Discussions reveal how Shakespeare presents the lovers as ridiculous rather than ideal, along with the complexities of Friar Lawrence's motives. The commentary touches on the social stakes in Verona and critiques the impetuous decisions that lead to tragic outcomes, showcasing the layers of irony in this classic tale.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Stars As Determinism
- Shakespeare uses astrology and 'stars' as a genuine metaphor for fate that his characters take seriously in the play's world.
- The phrase 'star-crossed lovers' signals external destiny shaping Romeo and Juliet's misfortune, not a simple romantic blessing.
Hosts' Favorite Film Versions
- Drew likes the 1996 film with Leonardo DiCaprio for its dark tone and emphasis on inter-family violence.
- Sean prefers spectacle like Zeffirelli, but criticizes sentimental productions.
BBC 1978 Casts Juliet Aged 14
- Sean prefers the BBC 1978 Romeo and Juliet because it cast a 14-year-old Juliet and resisted sentimental readings.
- Critics objected, but the production makes Juliet's youth and impulsiveness clearer.











