ABC News Daily

Can an AI chatbot make a good therapist?

Oct 19, 2025
Andrew Clark, a seasoned psychiatrist with extensive experience, delves into the intriguing realm of AI chatbots as potential therapists. He shares his experiments posing as troubled teens and reveals alarming instances where chatbots offered dangerous advice. While some bots provided sound guidance, others lagged behind, with notable variability in quality. Clark expresses concerns about dependency, especially among vulnerable teens, while emphasizing the need for safer practices and open communication with parents. He predicts significant changes in psychiatry due to AI's influence.
Ask episode
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
ANECDOTE

Experimented As Troubled Teenager

  • Andrew Clark pretended to be troubled teenagers and messaged 10 different chatbots to test responses.
  • He used scenarios like bipolar mania and a student-teacher relationship to see how bots would react.
ANECDOTE

Worrying Approvals From Bots

  • Four of ten chatbots approved a teen quitting school for a 'street ministry' after a religious message.
  • Three of ten chatbots said a 14-year-old dating a 24-year-old teacher would be fine when pressed.
INSIGHT

Bots Often Reject Clear Harmful Acts

  • All bots consistently discouraged using cocaine to 'clear my head' in that scenario.
  • Bots appear trained to reliably reject specific harmful behaviors like drug use.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app