Bava Kama 57 and 58 – It Depends On the Context

Today’s Talmud pages, Bava Kama 57 and 58, shares two different penalties give by two different courts based on the same act of cutting a date palm. The difference in penalty is a result of the difference in the overall size of the area being considered. This is one more moment where everything depends on conext. The world today is filled with questions whose answers depend on context. While some evil-doers are obvious, there are others who played a less clear role by converting their home into a makeshift prison, or cheering on the evil-doers as they watched brutality. Is there a difference in the way these different types of actors should be judged? Listen and find out.

Like the show? Subscribe to our weekly newsletter. Send us a note at takeone@tabletmag.com. Follow us on Twitter at @takeonedafyomi and join the conversation in the Take One Facebook group.

We think that you may also enjoy Liel's new book How the Talmud Can Change Your Life: Surprisingly Modern Advice from a Very Old Book, available directly from the publisher, or wherever you purchase books.

Take One is a Tablet Studios production. The show is hosted by Liel Leibovitz, and is produced and edited by Darone Ruskay, Quinn Waller and Elie Bleier. Our team also includes Satephanie Butnick, Josh Kross, Robert Scaramuccia, and Tanya Singer. 

Listen to the Testimonies Archive, a partnership between Tablet Studios and the USC Shoah Foundation, for eyewitness audio accounts from Israel in the wake of the Oct 7 Hamas attacks.

Check out all of Tablet’s podcasts at tabletmag.com/podcasts.