Annie Karni, a Capitol Hill correspondent for The New York Times, delves into the internal GOP turmoil surrounding Speaker Mike Johnson, driven largely by discontent from women in the party. She discusses explosive criticisms, including accusations of dishonesty and gender insensitivity, triggered by Johnson’s controversial remarks. Karni highlights the impact of the Epstein files vote, Trump's looming influence, and the potential for leadership change. The conversation reveals a fractured party grappling with identity, loyalty, and looming electoral challenges.
33:30
forum Ask episode
web_stories AI Snips
view_agenda Chapters
menu_book Books
auto_awesome Transcript
info_circle Episode notes
insights INSIGHT
Public Revolt Cuts Across Factions
Republican anger at Mike Johnson is unusually public and spans multiple factions of the conference.
Annie Karni notes members are openly attacking him on the record, not just on background.
insights INSIGHT
Epstein Vote Sparked Broader Fallout
The Epstein discharge fight catalyzed broader dissatisfaction with Johnson's leadership.
Karni links that episode to growing public fractures and resentment within the GOP conference.
insights INSIGHT
Cultural Clash Over Gender Roles
Cultural fit and Johnson's evangelical, traditional views on gender fuel friction with female colleagues.
Members say his podcast comments and attitudes make women feel unheard and culturally distant from him.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
How did the Epstein files vote spark an all-out revolt against Speaker Mike Johnson from the very women in his own party?
On this explosive episode of the Tara Palmeri Show, New York Times Capitol Hill correspondent Annie Karni pulls back the curtain on the growing Republican fury at Mike Johnson – from Elise Stefanik calling him a habitual liar, Nancy Mace fuming over his treatment of women, and Marjorie Taylor Greene labeling him weak, to a broader meltdown over leadership, redistricting, and Trump’s shadow presidency. The two veteran reporters dig into Johnson’s old podcast comments on “waffle vs spaghetti” brains, why GOP women feel he doesn’t listen to them, the real threat of mid-term retirements, and whether anyone (Tom Emmer?) could actually replace him before the majority vanishes.
Read Annie’s must-read piece that has all of Washington buzzing:
https://www.nytimes.com/2025/12/03/us/politics/republican-women-speaker-johnson.html
Who do you think lasts longer in 2026 – Mike Johnson as Speaker or the razor-thin Republican House majority? Drop your prediction below.
For more of her reporting, subscribe to her weekly newsletter, "The Red Letter." https://tarapalmeri.substack.com/
https://www.tarapalmeri.com/subscribe
Latest from the Red Letter:
https://www.tarapalmeri.com/p/george-santos-believes-george-santos
https://www.tarapalmeri.com/p/power-shifts-everywhere
https://www.tarapalmeri.com/p/did-trump-just-slap-his-name-on-obamacare
To support her mission of independent journalism, consider donating to her GoFundMe account: https://gofund.me/0c46f9a5
Annie Karni's profile at NYT:
https://www.nytimes.com/by/annie-karni
Follow Annie:
https://x.com/anniekarni
https://www.instagram.com/anniekarni/
Tara Palmeri is one of the most feared and fearless reporters covering power and politics. She has 15 years of experience covering national politics and foreign affairs. She was formerly a White House Correspondent for ABC News where she covered the first Trump administration. She was the chief National Correspondent for POLITICO during the Biden administration. She has been a political analyst for CNBC, CBS and CNN. She started her career as a columnist for the Washington Examiner and then went on to report for the New York Post. She was a foreign correspondent for POLITICO Europe, where she covered international affairs, including Brexit. She hosted the Ringer's political podcast "Somebody's Gotta Win" and wrote a column for Puck. Tara also hosted two acclaimed podcasts on Jeffrey Epstein, "Broken: Jeffrey Epstein" and "Power: The Maxwells." Tara currently hosts the Tara Palmeri Show.
Follow Tara:
https://www.instagram.com/tarapalmeri/
https://x.com/tarapalmeri
https://www.tiktok.com/@tarapalmeri
For inquiries, email: TaraPalmeriInfo@gmail.com
#MikeJohnson #SpeakerJohnson #EpsteinFiles #EliseStefanik #NancyMace #MTG #MarjorieTaylorGreene #GOP #HouseRepublicans #PoliticalScandal #TaraPalmeriShow #TaraPalmeri
Inside the GOP Mutiny Over Mike Johnson and the Epstein Files
Chapters:
00:00 Welcome to the Tara Palmeri Show
01:50 Annie Karni joins the Tara Palmeri Show
04:19 Republican anger erupts at Johnson on the record
06:04 Why the women are leading the revolt
08:12 Mike Johnson’s traditional views on gender roles
10:19 Waffle vs spaghetti brains and Thanksgiving dinner
11:54 Epstein vote pressure from Johnson and Trump
14:15 Trump as shadow Speaker
17:25 No loyalty owed – Johnson didn’t build the majority
21:00 Mid-term retirements and slim majority panic
24:39 How Mace, Boebert and MTG stood up to Trump
27:35 Some GOP women still defend Johnson
28:47 Thanks for watching the Tara Palmeri Show