Is Islamic Banking TRULY Islamic? | Harris Irfan - Muslim Money Talk Ep 23
Dec 9, 2024
auto_awesome
Harris Irfan, a veteran in Islamic finance, offers a critical perspective on the industry's adherence to foundational principles. He discusses the need for innovation to align modern practices with prophetic economics. The conversation delves into the disconnect between demand and actual use of Islamic financial products, while promoting Bitcoin as a 'freedom currency.' Irfan also highlights fintech's potential to bridge gaps in Islamic finance and emphasizes the importance of ethical leadership and genuine risk-sharing instruments.
Islamic banks are often criticized for mimicking conventional finance, failing to meet the true ethical needs of the Muslim community.
The podcast highlights the importance of innovative fintech solutions that prioritize risk-sharing and align with prophetic economic principles.
Promoting Bitcoin as a freedom currency presents an alternative financial independence avenue for Muslims seeking ethical economic practices.
Deep dives
The Flaws of Conventional Banking Systems
The podcast critiques the current banking systems, particularly highlighting the issues within Islamic finance. It emphasizes that Islamic banks often replicate conventional banking practices, leading to a scenario where money is created out of nothing, resembling legalized fraud. The discussion suggests that despite their intentions, Islamic banks are failing to address the financial needs of the Muslim community effectively. This failure highlights the necessity for a new approach, driven by experienced professionals who can innovate beyond conventional methods.
The Importance of First Principles in Financial Innovation
The discussion underscores the need for a shift towards understanding and applying first principles in the creation of financial instruments. It argues that much of the Islamic finance industry is bogged down by traditional practices, which do not reflect the core values of Islamic economics. By breaking away from conventional banking structures, there is an opportunity to develop financial products that align with true risk-sharing principles. This approach not only promotes better partnerships between investors and companies but also fosters a more ethical financial environment.
Challenges Faced Within the Islamic Banking Sector
The podcast delves into the challenges Islamic banks face, particularly their reluctance to innovate and their reliance on conventional financial models. The culture within these banks tends to prioritize job security over genuine innovation, resulting in a stagnation of progress. Specifically, products like commodity murabaha are criticized for being too similar to conventional loans, failing to meet the true spirit of Islamic finance. The speaker stresses the need for a radical restructuring of how Islamic finance operates to genuinely serve the community's needs.
The Rise of Fintech as a Solution
Fintech is proposed as a viable solution to the shortcomings of traditional Islamic banking. The podcast highlights the emergence of fintech companies that aim to innovate and address specific financial problems without the constraints of conventional banking. By focusing on real economy-based solutions and risk-sharing models, these startups could significantly improve user experience and customer service in the financial sector. The speaker emphasizes that successful fintech ventures will require high-quality talent and a deep understanding of both financial regulations and consumer needs.
Vision for a Resilient Economic Future
The conversation culminates in a vision for a more resilient and ethical economic future, underpinned by the principles of prophetic economics. It advocates for the adoption of financial models based on equity and risk-sharing, steering clear of debt-centric structures. The speaker also calls for a broader acceptance of alternative forms of money, such as Bitcoin, as a means toward financial independence. This holistic approach could lead to sustainable growth and empowerment for communities historically underserved by conventional financial systems.
In this special podcast episode, Harris Irfan, a veteran in Islamic finance, critiques the industry for not adhering to its foundational principles and discusses innovative solutions for real-economy, risk-sharing financial instruments.
He emphasises the need for skills, innovation, and aligning modern Islamic finance practices with prophetic economic principles, while also advocating for Bitcoin as a freedom currency and discussing the future of Islamic fintech.
This podcast is powered by Kestrl.
Kestrl is an app that helps Muslim to grow their wealth without compromising their beliefs
Kestrl - The Muslim Money App
https://kestrl.io/
TIMESTAMPS:
00:00 - Coming Up
02:13 – Haris’s career journey and contrarian perspective in Islamic finance.
06:12 – Challenges faced by Muslims in conventional finance and career advice.
08:28 – Analysis of the disconnect between demand and use of Islamic financial products.
12:50 – Early days at Deutsche Bank and innovation in Islamic finance.
16:50 – Transition from conventional banking to Islamic fintech and ethical dilemmas.
24:41 – Issues in Islamic banking culture and reverse engineering of conventional banking products.
30:31 – Role of fintechs in addressing gaps in Islamic finance.
39:58 – Introduction to Cordoba Capital Markets and the Profit Participating Note (PPN).
52:14 – Discussion on AOFI Standard 62 and its implications for Sukuk.
58:02 – Pakistan’s aim to eliminate riba by 2028 and Bitcoin as freedom money.
1:09:50 – The role of prophetic values in building a better economic system.
1:11:25 – Advice for aspiring Islamic fintech entrepreneurs.
Remember Everything You Learn from Podcasts
Save insights instantly, chat with episodes, and build lasting knowledge - all powered by AI.
