The Big Five Podcast The Mark Carney train gets derailed - by his own ministers. Plus: Quebecers say we should tax the rich more.
May 15, 2025
Elias Makos talks with Anthony Koch, former spokesperson for Pierre Poilievre, and Jonathan Kalles, former advisor to Justin Trudeau. They delve into the political turmoil surrounding Mark Carney, exploring how his ministers are complicating his plans. They discuss Quebec's staggering $14 billion deficit and the public's desire to tax the wealthy rather than cut services. The conversation also touches on the evolving definitions of wealth in tax debates and the repercussions of immigration policies in light of budget management ahead of elections.
AI Snips
Chapters
Transcript
Episode notes
Carney's Mixed Ministerial Messaging
- Mark Carney's tax cut announcement was overshadowed by inconsistent messaging from his ministers.
- Ministers showed lack of preparation, harming the government's credibility early on.
Carney Needs To Show Contrast
- Carney's success hinges on proving he is different from Trudeau's government.
- His ministers' mistakes risk making voters see him as a Trudeau extension.
Housing Prices Must Decrease
- The housing minister's denial that prices must fall hurt public trust.
- Home prices need to drop to improve affordability, yet messaging failed to reflect this reality.