A critical review of the movie Napoleon, highlighting its historical inaccuracies, the portrayal of Napoleon as passive and unintelligent, and the missed opportunities in capturing his essence. The chapter also discusses the impressive costumes and set design, the well-shot execution scene, and praises Vanessa Kirby's performance as Josephine and the actor who played Talirond. The podcast analyzes the performances in the movie and shares a humorous moment involving the arrest of a member of the directory.
Read more
AI Summary
AI Chapters
Episode notes
auto_awesome
Podcast summary created with Snipd AI
Quick takeaways
The movie 'Napoleon' fails to accurately portray Napoleon Bonaparte's intelligent and charismatic nature, instead presenting him in a passive and empty manner.
Ridley Scott's direction undermines Napoleon's leadership qualities by depicting him as an ineffective and strategically inactive figure, failing to showcase his significant victories.
Deep dives
Historical Inaccuracies and Lack of Character Development
The podcast discusses the movie 'Napoleon' and its various shortcomings. The host mentions the historical inaccuracies portrayed in the film, such as Napoleon's passive and empty portrayal as opposed to his actual intelligent and charismatic nature. Ridley Scott, the director, is criticized for not accurately capturing Napoleon's character and instead creating a movie that seems to have contempt for him. The lack of depth in the portrayal of his relationship with Josephine is also highlighted, as there is no warmth, understanding, or love shown between them.
Negative Depiction of Napoleon's Leadership
The podcast points out the movie's tendency to undermine Napoleon's leadership qualities and portray him as ineffective. It is mentioned that he is shown as a passive figure who does not actively lead or make strategic decisions during battles. Ridley Scott's approach of disconnecting Napoleon from his accomplishments and refusing to showcase his leadership abilities is criticized, resulting in a lack of understanding of the significance and impact of his victories.
Highlighting the Few Redeeming Aspects
Despite its flaws, the podcast acknowledges a few positive elements of the movie. The costuming and set designs are praised for their realism and visual appeal. Some scenes, such as Marie Antoinette's execution and the survivors' ball, are noted for effectively capturing the historical context and the emotions of the time. The performances of certain actors, including Vanessa Kirby as Josephine, are appreciated alongside well-executed effects and shots.
Overall Assessment of the Movie
In summary, the podcast presents a critical assessment of the movie 'Napoleon.' It highlights the historical inaccuracies, lack of character development, negative depiction of Napoleon's leadership, and the missed opportunities to create a more compelling cinematic experience. Despite a few commendable elements, the movie fails to capture the true essence of Napoleon and his historical significance.
My review of the Ridley Scott directed movie, Napoleon. I go through what I liked and didn't like, some of the historical inaccuracies, and how the movie could have been better.
-----
Sponsors:
Premium Feed - To hear every episode as it comes out, including endnotes, bonus episodes, and mini-episodes.
Tamba.Digital - For all of your website, web app, and mobile app design needs
Founders Podcast - To learn about the lives of even more great entreprenuers