Discover the chilling disappearance of Roger 'Fred' Farmer, unveiling alarming family dynamics and unsettling text messages. The investigation reveals suspicious financial activities linked to his son, Jeremy, and uncovers a web of contradictions in their stories. As Detective Krasenoy delves deeper, family tensions and secrets emerge, leading to a shocking discovery in a storage unit. The saga unfolds with the haunting implications of personal relationships and the quest for justice against the backdrop of a tragic family history.
The investigation into Roger 'Fred' Farmer's disappearance revealed critical evidence pointing to his son Jeremy's involvement in possible foul play.
Fred's daughters mourn not just their father's loss but also the fractured family dynamics resulting from their brother's actions.
Deep dives
Suspicious Disappearances
The case begins with the disappearance of Roger 'Fred' Farmer, who was reported missing in late December 2019. His daughter, Christina, noted that the texts she and her sister received from Fred were out of character, indicating they were likely not sent by him, as he typically used a simple talk-to-text style. Concerned, Christina checked Fred's home and found that his bank account was in the negative, which was unusual for him, further fueling worries for his well-being. As the investigation unfolds, it is revealed that Fred had been missing since early November, leading detectives to suspect foul play rather than a simple disappearance.
Family Ties and Financial Motives
Detective Larry Krasenoy discovers that Fred's son, Jeremy, was living with him and had a contentious relationship with his father. Financial discrepancies become apparent, as Fred had reported fraudulent charges to his accounts shortly before his disappearance. Analyzing text messages and observing unusual activity in Fred's financial records, detectives suspect Jeremy may have been stealing from his father to support a lifestyle that included frequent bar visits, which was contrary to Fred's usual habits. Compounding suspicions is a purchase Jeremy made at a hardware store just days before Fred vanished, which becomes pivotal evidence in the case.
Uncovering the Truth
Through meticulous investigation, the detectives uncover critical evidence pointing toward Jeremy's involvement in his father's disappearance. A search of Fred's home reveals a room with missing carpet, suggesting potential cleaning of a crime scene, and the presence of Fred's dentures signals foul play. When the police investigate a storage unit rented by Jeremy, they discover a trash can containing Fred's remains, concealed to prevent detection. Along with evidence of Jeremy's fingerprints and DNA on the trash can, the connection implicates him as a prime suspect in his father's murder.
Trial and Legacy of Fred Farmer
Jeremy Farmer is ultimately charged and tried for his father's murder, presenting a self-defense claim during the trial. However, the jury finds him guilty, and he is sentenced to 57 years in prison. Despite this conviction, Fred's daughters grapple with the loss of both their father and brother, as they feel the repercussions of Jeremy's actions extend beyond the courtroom. They reflect on their father's life with fondness, ensuring that while the circumstances were tragic, his memory is honored for the love and joy he brought to their lives.
As soon as Roger “Fred” Farmer’s family realizes they haven’t seen him in a few weeks, they suspect the worst. Despite all the breadcrumbs leading to one person, it takes time to piece the events of his disappearance together… and even longer to bring him justice.
Did you know you can listen to this episode ad-free? Join the Fan Club! Visit crimejunkie.app/library/ to view the current membership options and policies.