JD Vance, a newly appointed senator from Ohio and Donald Trump's running mate, faces intense scrutiny after controversial remarks about 'childless cat ladies' and voting dynamics. In the discussion, his unpopularity and its potential impact on the Trump campaign are analyzed. The hosts delve into how opponents are using Vance's past comments for attack ads, and the shifting strategies Democrats are adopting. They also address the challenges emerging politicians face in an increasingly confrontational political landscape.
J.D. Vance's unexpected unpopularity raises concerns for Trump's campaign, revealing a disconnect between his past comments and voter sentiment.
Democrats are effectively using Vance's peculiar remarks to frame him as 'weird,' shifting their narrative to resonate with broader voter concerns.
Deep dives
J.D. Vance's Unpopularity in Early Polling
J.D. Vance is facing significant challenges in early polling after being nominated as Trump's vice presidential pick. Polls indicate that he is more unpopular than typical candidates at this stage, showing a higher number of voters with negative views compared to positive ones. This low favorability can be surprising given that vice presidential selections usually experience a boost in public perception upon their introduction. Vance's underwhelming performance in the Ohio Senate race, where he won by a small margin compared to his Republican counterparts, raises concerns about his appeal among voters in both Ohio and key Midwest states.
Controversial Past Statements Resurface
Vance's earlier remarks, particularly his comments about 'childless cat ladies,' have resurfaced and are being used by Democrats in attack ads. These statements, made during his Senate campaign, highlight a divide between his views on family and the broader public sentiment, leading to questions about his approach and intent. His suggestions that childless individuals should potentially face higher taxes or that people with children should receive extra votes have aggravated these perceptions. His attempts to clarify these remarks by claiming they were sarcastic have not significantly mitigated the damage to his image.
Democratic Messaging Strategy Against Vance
Democrats are strategically framing Vance as 'weird,' a broad term that allows voters to interpret various negative connotations regarding his statements and overall persona. This approach contrasts with previous Democratic messaging focused on threats to democracy, utilizing a simpler and more relatable narrative. By highlighting Vance's odd upbringing and peculiar statements, Democrats are trying to create distance from the Trump campaign's more extreme elements. This shift in focus is expected to resonate with voters who seek relatable and coherent narratives, especially amid broader concerns leading up to the election.
It’s only been two weeks since JD Vance became Donald Trump’s running mate, and he’s already getting a lot of attention. But maybe not for the reasons Republicans wanted.
Past comments from the Ohio senator about “childless cat ladies” and parents having more voting power in elections have unleashed a flurry of criticism from Democrats. Vance’s comments also fueled a new line of attack from opponents who are deriding him as “weird.”
Co-host and senior political reporter Aaron Blake speaks with “Campaign Moment” podcast producer Laura Benshoff about all things Vance, and what his unusual unpopularity could mean for the Trump campaign.
Today’s show was produced by Laura Benshoff and mixed by Rennie Svirnovskiy. It was edited by Lucy Perkins and Mary Jo Murphy. Thanks also to Ali Bianco.
Subscribe to Aaron’s newsletter, The Campaign Moment, here.