Gwen Adshead, a seasoned forensic psychiatrist and psychotherapist with nearly 40 years of experience, tackles the complex nature of evil in her talk. She distinguishes between evil and mental illness, suggesting that the capacity for both exists within all of us. Adshead emphasizes the importance of emotional education in preventing violence and discusses the societal implications of labeling individuals as 'evil.' By exploring the roots of rage and the role of faith in rehabilitation, she advocates for compassion and a deeper understanding of violent behavior.
The concept of evil is complex and intertwined with mental health, suggesting that one's actions do not solely define their character.
Emotional regulation and societal influences play critical roles in the capacity for violence, highlighting the need for effective coping mechanisms and support systems.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Evil
The concept of evil is not a straightforward classification but rather a complex idea that exists within all individuals. It is important to recognize that while some may commit heinous acts, this does not intrinsically label them as evil. The capacity for evil is intertwined with human experiences and can manifest due to various psychological factors, including severe mental illness, trauma, and substance abuse. Understanding this complexity allows for a more nuanced view of individuals who commit violent acts, as opposed to merely categorizing them as irredeemably evil.
Factors Leading to an Evil State of Mind
Several psychological components contribute to an evil state of mind, often emerging from cognitive distortions and hyper-individualism. Individuals may develop rigid ways of thinking that exclude empathy and compassion, leading them to view others as mere objects or obstacles. This dangerous mindset is often combined with feelings of entitlement and the creation of personal moral rulebooks that disregard societal norms. Understanding these factors helps to elucidate why some ordinary individuals may commit cruel acts under specific circumstances while still retaining the capacity for goodness.
The Role of Emotions in Violence
Emotional regulation plays a crucial role in the potential for violence, with various emotions acting as precursors to aggressive behavior. The seven deadly sins can be examined through a psychological lens, revealing how emotions such as anger and pride can drive individuals toward violence. While natural emotions can lead to positive actions when managed appropriately, unchecked emotions can spiral into states of hatred and aggression. This highlights the importance of emotional education in preventing acts of violence by helping individuals develop healthy coping mechanisms.
The Influence of Society and Community
The environment in which individuals grow up significantly influences their mental states and capacity for violence. Societal narratives, peer influences, and access to resources can exacerbate tendencies towards cruelty or lead to rehabilitation opportunities when managed effectively. It is imperative to address the root causes of violence, including societal inequalities and stresses, through public health approaches and community support systems. By recognizing that even ordinary people can become embroiled in violence under certain social conditions, measures can be implemented to foster environments that promote understanding and healing.
In her second Reith Lecture, Dr Gwen Adshead asks if there’s such a thing as “evil.”?
In a career spanning nearly 40 years the forensic psychiatrist has heard many of her patients ask: “ I have done evil things but does that make me evil.”?
Dr Adshead says that we have often confused “evil” with mental illness. She argues that we all have capacity for “evil” and says we need to find ways to cultivate societal and individual “goodness.”
The programme is recorded at the V&A in Dundee in front of an audience.
The Reith Lectures are presented and chaired by Anita Anand.
Producer: Jim Frank
Editor: Clare Fordham
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode