Dan Carlin, a historian and podcaster renowned for "Hardcore History," dives deep into the nature of evil, exploring the motivations behind notorious figures like Stalin and Hitler. He examines the dualities of patriotism and the complexities of power, particularly in authoritarian regimes like Russia under Putin. The conversation touches on the moral dilemmas faced by dissenters during oppressive regimes and reflects on the fragility of civilization amidst terrorism. Carlin emphasizes love, wisdom, and empathy as crucial responses to today's challenges.
The podcast explores the subjective definition of evil and the motivations behind inflicting suffering.
The distinction between violence and force is discussed, exploring the ethical implications of using force for the greater good.
The complexities of evaluating leaders like Vladimir Putin from different cultural and historical contexts are highlighted.
Hitler's rise to power was influenced by post-World War I Germany's context, inflation, and antisemitic ideology.
The path that led to Hitler's rise was influenced by the discredited Weimar Republic, economic hardships, and perpetuation of conspiracy theories.
Evil people may lack competence in carrying out destructive plans, showcasing a glimmer of hope for self-preservation.
Deep dives
The Complexity of Good and Evil
The podcast explores the philosophical question of whether humans are fundamentally good or capable of both good and evil. The discussion delves into the subjective definition of evil and the motivations behind inflicting suffering. It also examines historical figures like Stalin and Hitler, their perceived motives, and the ethical implications of their actions. The podcast highlights the challenges of defining evil and understanding the complexity of human nature.
The Relationship Between Violence and Force
The conversation delves into the distinction between violence and force, and their roles in human society. The idea that force may be necessary in certain circumstances to protect the greater good is explored. The discussion acknowledges that force can be intertwined with violence, but emphasizes the importance of safeguarding individual liberties and questioning the motivations behind using force. It also raises questions about the moral implications of employing force and the potential for manipulation in society.
Perspectives on Vladimir Putin
The podcast touches on the viewpoints surrounding Russian President Vladimir Putin. It discusses the concept of leadership and power, and the complexities of evaluating leaders from different cultural and historical contexts. The conversation highlights the Russian perspective of Putin as a stabilizing force amidst a history of corruption and economic instability, and how his leadership is perceived as safeguarding the country. It also raises questions about succession and the future stability of Russia once Putin leaves office.
The Tragedy of Hitler's Rise
Hitler's rise to power in Nazi Germany was influenced by the context of post-World War I Germany, inflation, and dissatisfaction with the Weimar Republic. The hatred for Jews and the conspiracy theory that they controlled the world became an integral part of Hitler's ideology. The Holocaust, a dark and tragic part of history, was a result of Hitler's obsession with antisemitism and the belief that Jews were enemies within. The hatred towards Jews wasn't necessary for the rise of fascism, but it played a significant role in Hitler's worldview.
The Potential to Stop Hitler
There were various possibilities to stop Hitler's rise. One notable opportunity was during Hitler's remilitarization of the Rhineland, where a French intervention could have thwarted his plans and potentially led to his downfall. However, the conditions in Germany at the time, the discredited Weimar Republic, economic hardships, and the perpetuation of conspiracy theories made it difficult for alternatives to emerge. The hatred towards Jews was a unique and tragic aspect of the Nazi phenomenon, which overpowered other potential paths. However, removing Hitler alone wouldn't have eliminated the underlying trends and forces that allowed his rise.
The Possibility of Self-Destruction
The capability for evil doesn't necessarily correlate with competence. While evil genius ideas have been conceived throughout history, the constraints and challenges of implementing such ideas prevent them from reaching their full potential. The institutional stability of Germany during Hitler's rise and antisemitism contributed to the path that unfolded. However, the conspiracy theories and hatred towards Jews that became integral to Hitler's ideology showcased a tragic flaw. Antisemitism ultimately weakened Germany's intellectual capacity as Jewish scientists like Einstein were forced to leave. The Holocaust, with its irrational ideology, may ironically have prevented Germany from attaining nuclear weapons first. The notion that evil people lack competence in carrying out their destructive plans offers a glimmer of hope for the world's self-preservation.
The Challenges of Predicting Self-Destruction
The exact path toward self-destruction is difficult to determine, as multiple factors can contribute. Possibilities include nuclear weapons, societal breakdown, engineered pandemics, nanotechnology, artificial intelligence, and unforeseen circumstances. However, it is crucial to consider the collective ability to overcome such threats. Historical examples like the Cuban Missile Crisis demonstrate humanity's capacity to focus and make decisions that avoid catastrophic consequences. The hope lies in our ability to collectively work towards preventing self-destruction and continue striving for a better future.
The Power of Individual Leaders
The speaker emphasizes that individual leaders can make important decisions and influence events, contrasting it with collective decision-making. They discuss the difficulty of collectively taking care of the planet, as it requires sacrifices that not enough people are willing to make. The speaker presents a gambling man's view that charismatic leaders can inspire positive change and collaboration, but acknowledges the possibility of charismatic leaders emerging with harmful ideologies. They emphasize the importance of love and kindness in leadership.
Challenges to Unity and Hope for the Future
The discussion explores the challenges to unity, particularly in the current social media and political climate. The speaker discusses how media profit from widening divisions, and how governments may seek to control platforms that promote unity. They express concern about the potential for civil unrest and escalation of conflicts, leading to a desire for dictatorial rule. However, they also express hope in the transformative power of technology and the ability of individuals, like Elon Musk and podcasters, to unite people and bring positive change through empathy and reason.
The Influence of Big Companies on Podcasting
Many podcasters, including Joe Rogan, are faced with the challenge of monetization and navigating partnerships with big companies like Spotify. While there can be concerns about losing creative freedom or potentially compromising the content, partnering with a platform like Spotify can offer support in areas like technical maintenance and audience growth, which can be difficult for independent podcasters to manage. The key is to strike a balance between maintaining artistic integrity and considering the opportunities that partnerships with larger companies can bring.
The Never-Ending Quest for Quality in History Podcasting
As a long-time podcaster and history enthusiast, Dan Carlin emphasizes the importance of delivering quality content to his audience. He shares insights into his improvisational approach to creating episodes of Hardcore History and the extensive research and preparation that goes into each show. Carlin acknowledges the ever-changing nature of historical interpretation and scholarship, which continuously adds depth and new perspectives to the narratives. While historical events and figures like Alexander the Great and Hitler are on his radar for future episodes, the focus remains on providing immersive and thought-provoking storytelling while ensuring accuracy to maintain the trust of his dedicated audience.
Dan Carlin is a historian, political thinker, and podcaster. Please support this podcast by checking out our sponsors:
– Athletic Greens: https://athleticgreens.com/lex and use code LEX to get free vitamin D
– SimpliSafe: https://simplisafe.com/lex and use code LEX to get a free security camera
– Magic Spoon: https://magicspoon.com/lex and use code LEX to get free shipping
– Cash App: https://cash.app/ and use code LexPodcast to get $10
OUTLINE:
Here’s the timestamps for the episode. On some podcast players you should be able to click the timestamp to jump to that time.
(00:00) – Introduction
(07:53) – Nature of evil
(14:50) – Is violence and force fundamental to human civilization?
(19:58) – Will we always have war?
(29:38) – The Russian front in World War II
(37:32) – Ideologies of the US, the Soviet Union, and China
(50:15) – Putin
(1:02:50) – Journalism is broken
(1:10:16) – Genghis Khan
(1:24:36) – Greatest leader in history
(1:32:21) – Could Hitler have been stopped?
(1:49:21) – Hitler’s Antisemitism
(1:55:12) – Destructive power of evil
(2:04:26) – Will human civilization destroy itself?
(2:16:31) – Elon Musk, Tesla, SpaceX
(2:24:53) – Steering around the iceberg – wow do we avoid collapse of society?
(2:47:00) – Advice on podcasting
(2:50:12) – Joe Rogan, Spotify, and the future of podcasting
(3:05:19) – Future episodes of Hardcore History podcast
(3:20:21) – Is Ben real?
(3:21:05) – Meaning of life
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
