Investigative journalist Margaret Simons uncovers the downfall of China Matters, a key think tank, due to anti-China politicians called the Wolverines. They discuss defunding, accusations of espionage, and the government's response to alternative viewpoints on China.
China Matters defunded due to anti-China sentiment within Australian politics.
Closure of China Matters raised concerns about limited understanding and intellectual diversity in Australian policy circles.
Deep dives
Unpacking the Influence of China Matters
China Matters, a once prominent and pro-engagement organization, faced significant criticism and eventual defunding by the Morrison government. This scrutiny aligned with a shift towards tougher stances on China within Australian politics, including the banning of Huawei and enhanced foreign interference legislation. The group faced attacks from a coalition of politicians known as the Wolverines, who opposed China's influence and interference in Australia. The closure of China Matters highlighted the changing dynamics and concerns surrounding Chinese engagement.
Security Concerns Surrounding China Matters
Despite claims of a 'security concern,' the actual reasons behind the defunding of China Matters remained ambiguous and lacked clear evidence of wrongdoing. Allegations of potential Chinese influence and interference in Australian politics were raised, with specific focus on meetings and study tours involving members of the Communist Party. However, investigations failed to provide concrete evidence supporting these concerns, leaving doubts about the legitimacy of the security-related justifications.
Impact on Understanding China in Australian Politics
The demise of China Matters underscored a broader issue of limited depth in understanding China within Australia's foreign policy and defence circles. The episode highlighted challenges in maintaining alternative perspectives and voices on China, reflecting a potential stifling of dissenting viewpoints. The closure of China Matters raised questions about the balance between countering external autocratic influences and preserving intellectual diversity within Australia's policy discourse.
There's a shadow world beneath Canberra, fed by the defence, foreign affairs and security communities, and it is hugely influential in how the government responds to our biggest geopolitical challenges.
Margaret Simons has spent decades keeping a close eye on this world. Recently, the story of one think tank, China Matters, caught her attention.
The group, dedicated to bettering Australia’s understanding of China, was defunded during a time of aggressive posturing towards the superpower and talk of war.
Today, investigative journalist and contributor to The Monthly Margaret Simons on why this influential think tank came undone, and how a crew of anti-China politicians called the ‘Wolverines’ led the attack.