Making Marxism Great Again (End of the Flop Era) w/ Catherine Liu
Nov 23, 2024
auto_awesome
Catherine Liu, a Professor of Film and Media Studies at UC Irvine and author of 'Virtue Hoarders,' engages in a lively discussion about her political evolution as a Chinese-American scholar. She critiques the left's failings, emphasizing the need for systemic change in feminism and class struggles. Liu highlights the dissonance in political authenticity and the Democratic Party's missteps, particularly regarding voter dynamics. Her insights on the intersections of trauma, capitalism, and the importance of open dialogue make for an enlightening conversation.
Catherine Liu discusses the decline of public goods in America, highlighting the erosion of resources in education due to austerity measures.
Her personal experiences and exposure to Marxist dissidents informed a nuanced understanding of class struggles, shaping her leftist commitment.
Liu critiques the Democratic Party's alignment with professional managerial class interests, emphasizing the need for a focus on material issues affecting the working class.
Deep dives
Childhood Reflections on Class and Education
Growing up in the 1970s, the speaker experienced a more robust working-class culture in America compared to the austerity faced by younger generations today. Attending public school in a suburban area near New York City, the speaker recalls the availability of music lessons and well-resourced classrooms, highlighting how public goods were once prioritized. However, the decline in investment in public education due to tax revolts and austerity measures has led to a significant deterioration in resources, particularly in art and music programs. This transformation reflects broader societal shifts away from supporting public goods, which the speaker views as a profound loss of social democratic ideals.
Influence of Family Background and Cultural Exposure
The speaker's unique family background profoundly shaped their political views, particularly through their father's work at the United Nations and their frequent trips to China. Exposure to discussions among Marxist dissidents and a firsthand look at the complexities of life in China during the 70s and 80s informed a nuanced understanding of class struggles and anti-imperialism. These experiences cultivated a deep-seated suspicion of the Cold War narrative that characterized China as a totalitarian regime, contrasting with the positive developments the speaker observed in their family's life. This duality between personal experiences and ideological education laid the groundwork for the speaker's lifelong commitment to leftist principles.
Challenges in Academia and the Shift in Political Ideals
Navigating the academic landscape, the speaker encountered a dominant culture of postmodernism and feminism that often overshadowed traditional leftist thought. While grappling with the contradictions of second-wave feminism, the speaker sought to reconcile personal experiences with broader political ideologies, finding frustration in the prevailing narratives within cultural studies. The financial crisis of 2008 marked a turning point, prompting renewed interest in Marxism among students but also reflecting the persistent divide regarding class analysis. The speaker advocates for a historical materialist approach to understanding contemporary issues while critiquing the limited scope of current academic discussions.
The Gentrification of Trauma Studies
The speaker critically examines the emergence of trauma studies within the context of second-wave feminism, suggesting a shift towards individualization that undermined collective political action. Initially seen as a means to address the experiences of women, trauma discourse has transformed into a personal affliction, neglecting the broader class struggles that impact working-class individuals. This change reflects what the speaker terms the 'gentrification of suffering,' where elite narratives overshadow the material needs of marginalized groups. The focus on personal trauma diversion reflects a weakening of solidarity movements historically rooted in class struggle.
Political Disillusionment and Class Consciousness
The speaker expresses disillusionment with the Democratic Party's embrace of professional managerial class interests, which often overlooks the needs of working-class individuals. This disconnect has led to a notable shift in voter demographics, as increasingly more low-income individuals turn away from the party that takes their support for granted. The speaker argues that the focus on identity politics has diluted attention from the material issues impacting the working class, failing to address core economic stability. This sentiment resonates with a growing skepticism of neoliberal policies that prioritize corporate interests over genuine class solidarity.
Scholar and author of 'Vitrue Hoarders: The Case Against the Professional Managerial Class' Catharine Liu (@bureaucatliu) talks about her personal political journey as a Chinese-American within the trenches of western academia, where the Left went wrong, and her read on the 2024 elections. This is a super fun episode-- you're not going to want to miss it! Catherine is a gem.