Devin Fergus, “Land of the Fee: Hidden Costs and the Decline of the American Middle Class” (Oxford UP, 2018)
Jan 5, 2025
auto_awesome
Devin Fergus, Arvarh E. Strickland Distinguished Professor at the University of Missouri, dives deep into the unseen fees that subtly siphon wealth from the American middle class. He discusses how these hidden costs in housing, education, and transportation emerged from deregulation in the late 1970s. Fergus sheds light on the role of payday lending in perpetuating financial cycles of debt and critiques the auto insurance industry's biases against marginalized communities. His insights reveal the complex, often overlooked forces driving economic inequality in today’s society.
The proliferation of hidden fees in critical sectors like housing and education disproportionately burden the American middle class, highlighting the need for greater transparency.
Financial deregulation since the 1980s has empowered predatory lending practices, exacerbating debt and economic challenges for vulnerable populations.
Deep dives
The Rise of Fees and Financial Barriers
The discussion highlights how fees have increasingly become a significant barrier to mobility for the average American, spanning critical sectors such as housing, education, and employment. These fees not only include concrete charges like prepayment penalties and balloon payments but also encompass broader concepts like interest rates and additional costs associated with loans. The author underscores that the rise of fees since the 1980s reflects a shift in the financial landscape, driven largely by deregulation that enabled this growth in hidden costs. Consequently, these fees disproportionately impact those already facing economic challenges, exacerbating issues of accessibility and affordability in essential services.
Impact of Deregulation on Consumer Finance
The podcast delves into the consequences of financial deregulation, particularly focusing on the Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act of 1980, which allowed lenders to charge higher rates and fees. Initially believed to benefit consumers by increasing savings, the reality was that deregulation led to greater debt for Americans rather than financial security. This shift created an environment where institutions could exploit borrowers, particularly evident in the subprime mortgage crisis that later emerged. The author calls attention to how this law, once perceived as beneficial, ultimately paved the way for more exploitative lending practices.
The Role of the Donor Class
The talk highlights the influence of the donor class in shaping financial regulations and policies, illustrating how they have consistently prioritized their interests over consumers. The author notes that while they may not always be present at the inception of legislation, they often emerge as powerful defenders of deregulated industries, such as payday lending and auto insurance. This class has the ability to influence policymakers, effectively allowing predatory lending practices to persist despite the evidence of their adverse effects on vulnerable populations. The conversation emphasizes the need to scrutinize the motivations behind regulatory changes and their implications for the working and middle classes.
Payday Lending and Its Consequences
Payday lending is characterized as one of the most hazardous consumer financial products, with borrowers facing exorbitant costs due to high interest rates and roll-over fees. The process typically involves borrowing a small amount, which must be repaid within a short period, often leaving borrowers in a cycle of debt. Many borrowers struggle to repay just the principal amount, leading them to take out additional loans to cover previous debts, ultimately driving them closer to bankruptcy. The discussion points to the unique pressures that payday loans exert on individuals and families, showing how they can severely diminish financial stability and wellbeing.
Politicians, economists, and the media have put forth no shortage of explanations for the mounting problem of wealth inequality – a loss of working class jobs, a rise in finance-driven speculative capitalism, and a surge of tax policy decisions that benefit the ultra-rich, among others. While these arguments focus on the macro problems that contribute to growing inequality, they overlook one innocuous but substantial contributor to the widening divide: the explosion of fees accompanying virtually every transaction that people make.
As Devin Fergus, Arvarh E. Strickland Distinguished Professor of History, Black Studies, and Public Affairs at the University of Missouri, shows in Land of the Fee: Hidden Costs and the Decline of the American Middle Class (Oxford University Press, 2018), these perfectly legal fees are buried deep within the verbose agreements between vendors and consumers – agreements that few people fully read or comprehend. The end effect, Fergus argues, is a massive transfer of wealth from the many to the few: large banking corporations, airlines, corporate hotel chains, and other entities of vast wealth. Fergus traces the fee system from its origins in the deregulatory wave of the late 1970s to the present, placing the development within the larger context of escalating income inequality. He organizes the book around four of the basics of existence: housing, work, transportation, and schooling. In each category, industry lobbyists successfully influenced legislatures into transforming the law until surreptitious fees became the norm.
The average consumer is now subject to a dizzying array of charges in areas like mortgage contracts, banking transactions, auto insurance rates, college payments, and payday loans. The fees that accompany these transactions are not subject to usury laws and have effectively redistributed wealth from the lower and middle classes to ultra-wealthy corporations and the individuals at their pinnacles. By exposing this predatory and nearly invisible system of fees, Land of the Fee will reshape our understanding of wealth inequality in America.