Tim Keller, prominent theologian and pastor, discusses his evolving relationship with American Neo-Calvinism. The podcast explores his influences, his alignment with Kuiper and Voss, and his divergence from some theological visions. It also delves into the unique perspective of neo-Calvinists and analyzes Tim's synthesis of different paradigms for Christ and culture.
Tim Keller's relationship with neo-Calvinism evolved over time, from a distant association to openly embracing and identifying as a neo-Calvinist.
In 'Center Church', Keller engages with explicit and implicit forms of neo-Calvinism, acknowledging the distinctions and influences from theologians like Harvey Kahn and Ed Clowney.
Deep dives
Tim Keller's Engagement with Neo-Calvinism
Tim Keller's relationship with neo-Calvinism has evolved over time. In his book 'Center Church', he discusses the explicit American receptions of Abraham Kuiper's ideas, distinguishing between the Kuiperians and the neo-Calvinists. While he identifies more with the neo-Calvinist ministry expression of holistically educating Christians within culture, he does not closely align himself with any particular theological vision or doctrinal foundation. However, an implicit form of neo-Calvinism permeates 'Center Church', influenced by theologians like Harvey Kahn and Ed Clowney, who were disciples of Gerhardus Vos. This implicit neo-Calvinistic perspective shaped Tim Keller's view of the gospel and biblical theology throughout the book. Later in his life, Keller openly embraced neo-Calvinism, championing it and identifying himself as a neo-Calvinist. This shift was partially influenced by the availability of English translations of neo-Calvinist texts, helping him realize his connection to the tradition and the ability of neo-Calvinism to hold together his various commitments as a revivalist, pilotist, evangelist, and doctrinalist.
The Two Streams of Neo-Calvinism in 'Center Church'
In 'Center Church', Tim Keller engages with two streams of neo-Calvinism: the explicit American Kuiperian reception and the implicit American reception influenced by Gerhardus Vos. He acknowledges the Kuiperians' focus on controlling society politically, while the neo-Calvinists seek to transform society through Christian education and principled pluralism. While Keller maintains a distance when discussing the explicit forms, he approves of the doctrinal foundation and ministry expression of certain American neo-Calvinists. However, the book itself reflects an implicit neo-Calvinistic perspective. Important theologians like Harvey Kahn and Ed Clowney, who were shaped by Gerhardus Vos, influence Keller's view of the gospel, biblical theology, culture, and ministry. This implicit neo-Calvinism is deeply rooted within the book.
Tim Keller's Journey to Embracing Neo-Calvinism
Tim Keller's journey towards embracing neo-Calvinism was influenced by his theological education and exposure to neo-Calvinist sources. At Bucknell University, he encountered Hans Rocamacher's book, which highlighted the holistic nature of Christianity. Later, at Gordon-Conwell Theological Seminary, his professors, including Gerhardus Vos, exposed him to neo-Calvinistic ideas. Tim initially engaged with explicit neo-Calvinism cautiously in 'Center Church', but as he explored more neo-Calvinist texts in English translations, he began to identify himself as a neo-Calvinist. This allowed him to integrate his various commitments as a revivalist, pilotist, evangelist, and doctrinalist within the neo-Calvinistic framework. His journey demonstrates the significance of neo-Calvinist thought in shaping his theological development over time.
Resonance with Dutch Christians and Reflections on Dutch Heritage
Tim Keller's resonance with Dutch Christians highlights the importance of their own heritage and theologians. While Dutch Christians resonate with Keller, his thought and ideas are deeply rooted in Dutch tradition, influenced by theologians like Herman Bavink, J.H. Bavingk, Abraham Kuiper, and Gerhardus Vos. This resonance calls for a reevaluation of Dutch heritage and the recognition of resources within their own culture. Keller's emphasis on finding culturally respected sources within a culture serves as a reminder for Dutch Christians to utilize their own theological heritage as a valuable tool in engaging with their culture.
In his message at TGC Netherlands 2023, James Eglinton delves into Tim Keller's evolving relationship with Neo-Calvinism. He recommends Central Church by Tim Keller as the primary source for understanding Keller's mature theological voice and biblical basis for his ministry.
Eglinton's sermon discusses the evolution of Keller's thinking, showcasing a shift from a distant association with Neo-Calvinism to Keller explicitly identifying as a Neo-Calvinist in later years. Eglinton suggests that a careful examination of both explicit and implicit engagements with Neo-Calvinist thought in Center Church is essential to understanding Keller's theological journey.
Original conference media courtesy of: https://www.geloofstoerusting.nl/
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode