The Opinions There’s a Reason Even ‘Smart’ People Surrender to Trump
Feb 13, 2025
Masha Gessen, a prominent columnist and expert on authoritarianism, engages in a deep discussion about why numerous individuals and institutions have compromised their values in the face of Trump's influence. The conversation reveals the psychological factors behind compliance, exploring concepts like 'anticipatory obedience.' Gessen also critiques the challenges in uniting Americans for collective action, especially regarding marginalized communities, and reflects on personal safety and authenticity during these tumultuous times.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
Early Focus on Anti-Trans Rhetoric
- Masha Gessen was surprised by Trump's early focus on anti-trans rhetoric, particularly in his inaugural address.
- This was unexpected given the typical themes of such speeches, although Trump's was generally negative.
Reasons for Lack of Resistance
- Two reasons explain the lack of resistance to Trump's attacks: Democrats avoided engaging with anti-trans issues, leaving people without language to respond.
- Also, institutions and individuals prioritize providing care and avoiding attention, leading to anticipatory obedience.
Healthcare Provider's Dilemma
- A healthcare provider chose to remain anonymous to avoid attention and continue providing care to trans and immigrant patients.
- This demonstrates how individuals make humane but politically detrimental choices in response to Trump's actions.
