Jamie Hamilton: Time to break free of positionism

Oct 30, 2025

In this insightful conversation, Jamie Hamilton, a UEFA A Licence coach and influential football writer, critiques the dominance of positionalism in coaching. He emphasizes the importance of player individuality, arguing that rigid systems can stifle creativity and spontaneity. Jamie shares his journey and redefines tactical concepts, advocating for a shift towards relationism, which emphasizes player interactions over prescribed roles. He warns that over-coaching in youth football might hinder natural talent, urging coaches to embrace surprise and flexibility on the pitch.

Ask episode

AI Snips

Chapters

Books

Transcript

Episode notes

INSIGHT

Positional Play Creates Predictable Pockets

Guardiola-style positional play arranges players into zonal pockets to create 'free men' between defensive lines.
That specific possession method relies on predictable positioning and engineered space rather than spontaneous player choice.

ANECDOTE

Personal Shift After Watching Fluminense

Jamie felt tension coaching strict positional systems because he had to constantly tell players where to stand and what not to do.
He reconciled it until Fernando Diniz's Fluminense showed a different way to keep possession without rigid positional rules.

INSIGHT

Homogenization From Emulating Guardiola

Guardiola's success created a dominant global paradigm that many coaches copy without matching players or nuance.
Copy-paste adoption often yields formulaic teams lacking the original squad's generational talent.

Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode

Get the app

Our guest on Episode #74 of the TGG Podcast, in association with Teamworks, is Jamie Hamilton.

Jamie is a UEFA A Licence coach and has become one of the most important thinkers in football coaching, with his work on positionism and relationism.

This has struck a chord with coaches, players and fans, at all levels of the game, and is influencing a change of approach.

SHOW NOTES =>

01:50: Jamie's background - as a coach and writer.

04:06: How he first became interested in the concept of positionism. Influence of Pep Guardiola. Desire of positionists to turn chaos into order. Inspiration of Fernando Diniz at Fluminense.

19:20: Guardiola's teams becoming more controlled and ordered in the last five years. Finding Premier League teams more formulaic and less inspirational than they could be with the players available.

20:29: Coaches putting players into slots in pre-designed systems, rather than evaluating who you have, as people and players, and making the best of them.

31:38: Head Coach as a "top-down controller", thus constraining freedom. Enzo Maresca has said that there IS freedom - by virtue of the player receiving the ball having time and not being under pressure. But this is a certain definition of freedom and very different to the definition that a relational coach like Carlo Ancelotti would use. He gives his players freedom to move where they please too.

35:30: Defences are getting more attuned in how to combat positional systems. Becoming more physical, utilising man-to-man marking more. The inherent predictability of positional systems is being countered. So where now? This is where relational football can come in.

42:12: Coaches are worried about what happens when they lose the ball if they don't use positional systems. This isn't necessarily true though.

46:55: Teams have started using man-to-man pressing systems to combat positionalism, eg Bournemouth. This has led to teams hitting long balls into space with a classic number 9 chasing. Set pieces have also come more and more to the fore. There have been some creative solutions, eg Kane dropping very deep for Bayern Munich v Borussia Dortmund, but the most interesting solutions have tended to be outside the Premier League.

53:50: Bayern Assistant Rene Maric has said (on this podcast) that "tactics don't exist." Need for players to think in the moment.

56:52: Definition of relationism in layman's language. Positionism is zonal, inspired by handball. Relationism is non-zonal with exponents like Diniz, Ancelotti and Scaloni.

1:05:32: Need to let players play and not over coach. Good example of Messi and Suarez. Ability to let go and to be surprised.