They call us ‘settlers’ because they’re planning to kick us out
Nov 25, 2024
auto_awesome
In a thought-provoking discussion, Adam Kirsch, Editor at the Wall Street Journal and author of 'On Settler Colonialism', explores the unsettling rise of settler colonialism discourse. He exposes how this ideology labels non-Indigenous individuals as criminals in societies like Canada and Israel. Kirsch delves into the complexities of identity, historical injustice, and national belonging. He highlights the urgent need for a balanced understanding of Indigenous ties to land while unpacking tensions between Jewish and Palestinian narratives. This conversation challenges listeners to rethink their perspectives on history and justice.
The rising ideology of settler colonialism positions non-Indigenous individuals in Canada as illegitimate occupiers, influencing societal perceptions of national identity.
The complex historical context of Israel complicates the narrative of settler colonialism, challenging simplistic views that dehumanize individuals based on their ethnicity or national identity.
Deep dives
Understanding Settler Colonialism
Settler colonialism is increasingly recognized as a significant ideological framework within contemporary discussions surrounding historical injustices. This concept suggests that the establishment of nations like Canada, the United States, and Australia involved the ongoing process of invasion and occupation of indigenous lands, which remains relevant today. The term is often invoked in academic circles and is gaining traction in broader societal conversations, particularly regarding Israel and Palestine. This shift highlights the troubling implications of categorizing nations primarily as products of colonialism rather than acknowledging their complex historical narratives.
The Impact of Academic Ideology on Public Discourse
The intersection of settler colonialism with current political discourse is evident, particularly in the aftermath of events, such as the Hamas attack on Israel. Activists and scholars often use the framework of settler colonialism to characterize the Israeli state and its origins as inherently illegitimate, branding Israelis as colonizers. This perspective has led to disturbing rhetoric and protests that dehumanize individuals based on their national or ethnic identity. By framing Israeli citizens as 'settlers' rather than civilians, this ideology perpetuates a narrative that lacks room for mutual understanding and resolution.
Critique of the Settler Colonial Paradigm
Critical examination of the settler colonialism framework reveals its limitations, particularly when considering the unique historical context of Israel. Unlike traditional settler colonies where a foreign power governed territory, Israel emerged as a result of Jewish self-determination in their ancestral homeland, established in opposition to colonial powers. This crucial distinction highlights that both the Jewish population and Palestinians have deep historical connections to the land, complicating the binary categorization imposed by settler colonialism. Acknowledging this nuance is essential for fostering a productive dialogue on coexistence rather than perpetuating a narrative of division.
The Broader Societal Implications
The implications of viewing nations through the lens of settler colonialism extend into educational systems and public consciousness. The narrative has permeated schools, influencing how students perceive national identity and history, often emphasizing themes of guilt and illegitimacy. This ideological framing raises questions about the future of societies constructed on colonial histories and their ability to reconcile with indigenous populations. As discussions on these topics become more prevalent, there is a pressing need for balanced frameworks that encourage understanding and coexistence rather than reinforcing divisions.
You’re not welcome in “so-called Canada.” That’s what academics and activists call this country, which they declare “illegitimate.” And, as Adam Kirsch, author of the new book On Settler Colonialism tells Brian, these people aren’t using metaphors. They truly see anyone who isn’t Indigenous as an active colonizer and criminal who doesn’t belong. The idea is steadily gaining currency in our schools, society and government, and it’s brutally playing out against Israel, where Hamas supporters euphorically envision forcing out all Jews (despite the Jews’ own indigeneity). But don’t kid yourself, Kirsch warns: They’re working to dismantle other countries, too — especially this one. And with every land acknowledgment and libel against our nation’s history, we’re helping them do it. (Recorded November 15, 2024)