Another Way To Elect A President: The Presidential Electors (Part 5)
Oct 28, 2020
auto_awesome
Explore the intriguing role of the electors in the U.S. Electoral College. Discover how their votes are cast, and the potential pitfalls that can arise. Delve into the historical showdown between Jefferson and Burr, and how it influenced the creation of the 12th Amendment. Learn about the complexities behind electors' duties and the often-controversial winner-takes-all system. The conversation also addresses risks of bribery and the evolving debate on the future of this electoral mechanism.
The Electoral College was designed for electors to act independently, but modern practices often pressure them to follow party lines.
The shift to selecting party loyalists as electors has raised questions about the integrity of electoral votes and voter representation.
Deep dives
The Electoral College Process
Electors gather in their respective state capitals on a designated day set by Congress to cast their votes for president and vice president. This voting process is a ritual, characterized by ceremonial aspects, where electors vote separately for each position while ensuring that no two candidates are from the same state. Originally, the Constitution allowed electors to cast two votes, resulting in the top candidate assuming the presidency and the second becoming vice president, which led to complications in elections, notably in the year 1800. The introduction of the 12th Amendment established the current format where electors vote first for a president and then for a vice president to mitigate the issues created during the nation’s early elections.
Historical Context of the Electoral College
The framers of the Constitution created the Electoral College with the expectation that presidents would possess unifying qualities akin to George Washington, without the presence of divisive political parties. This expectation was proven flawed through early elections when rival politicians like Thomas Jefferson and John Adams were forced to work together as president and vice president despite their differences. The realization of this flawed system prompted reforms resulting in the understanding that electors should represent their state’s population rather than simply acting independently. This transition reflected a growing recognition that electors needed to align their decisions with the evolving political landscape and the will of the electorate.
The Mechanisms Behind Elector Selection
The selection of electors has evolved significantly, with many states now choosing party loyalists to represent them rather than letting the general populace vote directly for these positions. This shift has led to a winner-take-all approach for appointing electors in most states, where the political party receiving the plurality of votes acquires all electoral votes from that state. The initial intent behind establishing electors was to allow informed representatives to select a president independent of direct popular influence, fostering a system aimed at balancing power. However, modern practices often see electors voting in accordance with party mandates rather than exercising independent judgment.
Challenges Within the Current Electoral System
The tensions between electors' supposed independence and the pressures they face from party affiliations raise critical questions regarding the integrity of the electoral process. Recent elections have demonstrated dilemmas, as evidenced by discussions of 'faithless electors' who declare their intent to vote against the popular choice, prompting legal challenges and state-level punitive measures. While the Supreme Court has ruled that states can enforce pledges on how electors vote, concerns persist about whether this approach undermines the original purpose of the Electoral College. As the political landscape continues to shift, debates arise regarding the necessity of the Electoral College and the implications of maintaining this system in a modern democracy.
In this episode in our presidential election miniseries, we talk about the vote of the electoral college. Who are the electors, how do they cast their votes, and what could possibly go wrong?
Get the Snipd podcast app
Unlock the knowledge in podcasts with the podcast player of the future.
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode
Save any moment
Hear something you like? Tap your headphones to save it with AI-generated key takeaways
Share & Export
Send highlights to Twitter, WhatsApp or export them to Notion, Readwise & more
AI-powered podcast player
Listen to all your favourite podcasts with AI-powered features
Discover highlights
Listen to the best highlights from the podcasts you love and dive into the full episode