
The Coode Street Podcast Episode 635: On the nature of purpose in science fiction
A lively discussion about whether year's best anthologies can still capture a dispersed, international field. They debate how online publishing and mainstream outlets reshaped what counts as science fiction. They question sweeping labels like cyberpunk and explore how editor taste, discovery channels, and narrow versus broad collections shape what readers find.
01:04:12
Technology Made Short Fiction Untrackable
- Technology dramatically increased publishing access, exploding volume of short fiction and fragmenting venues.
- Jonathan Strahan notes his 2003 Year's Best process covered a handful of key magazines; that is no longer possible now.
State Your Anthology's Slice Clearly
- If you curate a Year's Best, be explicit about your slice and its criteria so readers can calibrate taste.
- Narrow anthologies (queer, African speculative) work; genre slices like 'hard SF' often lack consensus.
Impulse Reading An Advance Novel
- Gary K. Wolfe describes impulse reading Kelly Link's upcoming novel midstream despite a review pile.
- He used early novel exposure to explain how editors/advance copies and curiosity drive unexpected reading choices.
Get the Snipd Podcast app to discover more snips from this episode
Get the app 1 chevron_right 2 chevron_right 3 chevron_right 4 chevron_right 5 chevron_right 6 chevron_right 7 chevron_right 8 chevron_right 9 chevron_right 10 chevron_right 11 chevron_right 12 chevron_right 13 chevron_right 14 chevron_right 15 chevron_right 16 chevron_right 17 chevron_right 18 chevron_right 19 chevron_right 20 chevron_right 21 chevron_right
Intro
00:00 • 41sec
Hosts Catch Up and Travel Plans
00:41 • 39sec
Kansas City Guests of Honor
01:20 • 1min
Jonathan's British Fantasy Award Win
02:31 • 1min
Awards and Anthology Credit Issues
03:40 • 49sec
Can Year's Best Anthologies Still Work?
04:30 • 2min
Impact of Technology on Publishing
06:44 • 4min
Mainstream Novels as Science Fiction
10:50 • 2min
Narrowing to Micro Year's Bests
12:28 • 3min
How Do Readers Find New Books Today?
15:06 • 3min
Role of Recommendations and Social Media
17:56 • 6min
Which Year's Best Still Matter
24:14 • 3min
Editor Taste Shapes Anthologies
27:06 • 3min
Craft Versus Argument in Selection
29:37 • 6min
Why Readers Use Year's Best
35:31 • 4min
Anthologies' Primary Functions Today
39:43 • 5min
Best American Annuals and Literary Craft
44:51 • 5min
The Big Book of Cyberpunk Debate
49:50 • 6min
Defining Cyberpunk: Narrow Movement vs. Broad Term
55:38 • 2min
Labels, Waves, and Genre Categories
57:42 • 5min
Outro
01:03:02 • 1min

#122530
The Best American Short Stories 1986
Selected Stories (Short Cuts)


Raymond Carver
The Best American Short Stories 1986 is a yearly anthology in the Best American Short Stories series, guest-edited by Raymond Carver with Shannon Ravenel.
It collects a wide range of stories originally published in literary magazines and major periodicals, featuring work by writers such as Donald Barthelme, Ann Beattie, Richard Ford, Alice Munro, Grace Paley, Tobias Wolff, and others.

#129576
Someone in Time

Nina Allan

Jeffrey Ford

Zen Cho

Jonathan Strahan

Rowan Coleman
Someone in Time is a themed anthology edited by Jonathan Strahan that gathers contemporary short fiction exploring aspects of time and related speculative concerns.
The volume showcases a range of authors working across science fiction, fantasy, and horror, curated to highlight different imaginative approaches to temporality.
It was published by Solaris and received critical attention in 2023, including winning the British Fantasy Award for Best Anthology.
The collection serves both to introduce readers to a variety of new voices and to present notable work from established writers.
Its editor's selection aims to balance literary craft with the speculative premises implied by the book's theme.

#71609
Africa Risen

Zelda Knight

Oghenechovwe Donald Ekpeki


Sheree Renée Thomas
Africa Risen is a major anthology that collects speculative fiction stories from writers across Africa and the African diaspora, aiming to highlight the diversity and strength of contemporary African speculative voices.
Edited by a recognized editor (not specified in the podcast), the volume features a mix of established and emerging authors and has been influential in drawing attention to African contributions to science fiction, fantasy, and horror.
The anthology has received critical acclaim and awards recognition, contributing to conversations about representation and crediting contributors.
It serves both as a showcase for African speculative talent and as a corrective to historically narrow canons in the field.
The book is often referenced in discussions about expanding the scope of the genre internationally.
#53062
England swings SF

Judith Merril
England Swings SF is a 1968 anthology edited by Judith Merril that gathered work associated with the British new wave of the 1960s, introducing American readers to experimental and boundary-pushing fiction.
Merril's editorial program aimed to broaden the perception of what counted as science fiction by including writers and pieces that might otherwise be considered mainstream or literary.
The anthology is historically significant for its role in cross-pollinating Anglo-American speculative traditions and for pushing debates about genre boundaries.
Merril's selections often included surprising or unconventional voices, reflecting her belief that speculative concerns appeared throughout literature.
The volume remains a cited example of anthologists using curated collections to argue for an expanded definition of the field.
#128119
Light years and dark

Michael Bishop
Light Years and Dark is an anthology compiled by Michael Bishop that curated a selection of notable speculative short fiction, exposing readers to a variety of voices and styles.
The book functioned as a discovery vehicle for many readers, who encountered authors they later followed more closely.
As an editor, Bishop favored stories that combined literary quality with speculative imagination, and the anthology reflected those tastes.
The collection was discussed in the podcast as an example of how anthologies can broaden a reader's awareness of authors and influence subsequent reading choices.
Anthologies like this have historically played a key role in shaping readership and career trajectories for authors.
#69631
The Big Book of Cyberpunk

Jared Shuren
The Big Book of Cyberpunk is an expansive anthology that assembles a substantial number of stories and materials associated with cyberpunk, aiming to demonstrate the movement's breadth and influence.
Organized as several large sections, the collection includes both canonical pieces and wider-textured items that show cyberpunk's historical roots and later adaptations.
Contributors to the discussion in the podcast noted the anthology's scale and the editorial choice to include works outside narrow definitions of cyberpunk.
While offering a wealth of material for readers and scholars, the book's size and scope raise questions about whether a single volume can definitively represent such a varied phenomenon.
Nonetheless, it functions as a major repository for readers seeking an immersive view of cyberpunk-related fiction.
#50926
The Embroidered Book

Kate Heartfield
The Embroidered Book is a novel by Kate Heartfield that combines historical detail with speculative or fantastical elements, centering on characters whose lives are reshaped by extraordinary occurrences.
Praised for its narrative drive and atmospheric setting, the book appealed to readers who enjoy literary treatments of speculative premises.
It received recognition in Canadian literary circles, including award attention noted in the podcast.
Heartfield's work often emphasizes character relationships and moral complexity within speculative frameworks, and this novel continued in that vein.
The Embroidered Book helped broaden her readership among fans of both historical fiction and genre-blending narratives.
#44052
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
Starlinghouse

Alex Harrow

#21818
• Mentioned in 3 episodes
Cahokia Jazz

Francis Spufford
In 'Cahokia Jazz', Francis Spufford reimagines American history by positing a world where European colonization did not decimate indigenous populations.
The story is set in the state of Cahokia, carved out of eastern Missouri and surrounding states, in the 1920s.
Detectives Joe Barrow and Phineas Drummond are tasked with solving a gruesome murder that leads them into a complex web of politics, culture, and crime.
The novel blends elements of noir fiction, jazz age atmosphere, and a richly realized modern indigenous society, creating a unique and compelling narrative.

#29893
• Mentioned in 2 episodes
The Ten Thousand Doors of January

Alex Harrow
#108030
Mirror Shades
An Anthology of Cyberpunk


Bruce Sterling
Publiée en 1986 et éditée par Bruce Sterling, 'Mirror Shades' compile textes et essais qui ont contribué à définir le courant cyberpunk.
L'anthologie rassemble auteurs et nouvelles montrant des futurs urbains, des mégacorporations et des interfaces homme‑machine.
Elle documente la transition d'imaginaires SF vers des visions plus sombres et hyper‑modernes de la technologie.
L'ouvrage a aidé à formaliser la sensibilité esthétique et politique du cyberpunk, influençant aussi bien la littérature que le cinéma et les cultures numériques.
'Mirror Shades' reste une référence pour qui veut comprendre les racines du regard critique sur la technologie contemporaine.

#17790
• Mentioned in 4 episodes
The Book of Love

Kelly Link
Kelly Link's "The Book of Love" is a captivating novel that seamlessly blends magical realism with compelling characters and intricate plotlines.
The story unfolds in a series of interconnected narratives, each exploring different facets of love, loss, and the power of storytelling.
Link's signature blend of fantasy and reality creates a unique and immersive reading experience.
The novel's exploration of complex relationships and the unexpected beauty of life makes it a truly unforgettable read.
The magical elements are woven into the fabric of the narrative, enhancing the emotional depth and thematic resonance.
Responding in part to some issues raised by Niall Harrison in The Los Angeles Review of Books, Jonathan and Gary discuss the value and purpose of year’s best anthologies, whether it’s even possible to still represent such a diversified international field, and how stories we read in anthologies frame our own reading experiences and help us discover exciting new writers. Needless to say, a lot of digressions leads us into some other topics as well.
