The Times of Israel Daily Briefing Day 715 - Daniel Gordis: The lonely man of Zionism
15 snips
Sep 20, 2025 
Daniel Gordis, an insightful author, scholar, and rabbi, dives into the complexities of modern Zionism and Jewish identity. He shares the origins of his Substack, 'Israel from the Inside', championing a more nuanced pro-Israel stance in a challenging global climate. Gordis discusses the loneliness faced by Israelis during the High Holidays and critiques the oversimplified narratives that alienate diaspora Jews. He urges a deeper understanding of the ongoing struggles in Israel, all while emphasizing that honest critique is rooted in love.
AI Snips
Chapters
Books
Transcript
Episode notes
How The Substack Began
- Daniel Gordis started his Substack 'Israel from the Inside' in May 2021 after missiles fell on Jerusalem during a Hamas kerfuffle.
- He launched it impulsively while biking, deciding if he didn't start then he never would.
Letters That Cost Friendships
- Gordis and colleagues wrote public letters urging American Jewish leaders to oppose Israel's judicial overhaul and got pushback and lost friendships.
- They chose Times of Israel as a neutral platform and revised the letters carefully before publishing.
Criticism Is Part Of Love
- Gordis argues love and patriotism require criticism, delivered thoughtfully and at the right time and place.
- He rejects the idea that criticism equals disloyalty and says open critique can deepen commitment.
